Skip to main content

Topical question asked in the House of Commons, by Christine Russell (Labour). It was answered on Monday, 18 May 2009 on behalf of the Home Office.


Topical Questions

Question
Most people find the presence of CCTV in their neighbourhoods reassuring, and most police officers find them very helpful in assisting the detection of crime and the reduction of antisocial behaviour. However, there is also a strong view out there that they can result in a real invasion of an individual's personal liberty. Has the Department commissioned, or will it consider commissioning, a fully independent survey of the effectiveness of CCTV cameras?
Answer

My hon. Friend has raised an important point about the balance between the rights of the individual and the protection of the community. The Home Office is examining the way in which we manage CCTV systems throughout the country, and also the possibility of establishing a national CCTV board. According to a recent report from the Campbell Collaboration crime and justice group, CCTV has""a modest but significant desirable impact on crime"." The report says that it is most effective in reducing crime in car parks and targeting vehicle crime, and that it is more effective in reducing crime in the United Kingdom than in other countries. I think that that is an endorsement of CCTV, but we must of course consider the impact on the privacy of the individual as well.


Secondary information

Type
Oral question
Reference
492 c1202 
Session
2008-09
Oral question type
1st Supplementary
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
CCTV
Link
View this Topical question on www.publications.parliament.uk