Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Sainsbury of Turville (Labour) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 25 April 2006. It occurred during Debate on bill and Committee proceeding on Company Law Reform Bill [HL] 2005-06.


Company Law Reform Bill [HL]

Then I shall deal with the bureaucracy aspect now and with the issue of the dreadful trade unions marauding on the institutions at a later stage. Quite simply, the Government want to encourage greater transparency and accountability of institutional investors in demonstrating how they manage assets on behalf of their clients or members. We believe that this power is an important tool to that    end. The proposed amendments recommend narrowing this general power so that the Government could compel the disclosure only of voting instructions. Amendments Nos. A256A and A256E would permit the Government to require disclosure only of voting instructions, rather than a range of circumstances, including, for example, how votes are actually exercised. As noble Lords well understand, the distinction between voting instructions and how votes are actually cast is important. The process for many institutional shareholders of exercising their voting rights often involves a range of intermediaries acting on multiple shareholders’ instructions and it can sometimes be difficult to identify exactly whether the voting instructions were carried out and the votes cast. The Government are mindful of the cost implications of verifying voting instructions in these circumstances. But while voting instructions are a very important indication of voting intent, it is how—and, indeed, whether—votes are cast that ultimately determines how companies are governed, what resolutions are passed and what directors get appointed. It would therefore be premature for the Government to narrow this power until it is clear what will best deliver the Government’s goals in this area and whether it would be more effective to focus on how votes are cast or how institutional investors have instructed their agents to vote on their behalf. Retaining the wider power will enable the Government to shape any disclosure regime in more ways than simply requiring disclosure of how voting rights were exercised or what instructions were issued. This flexibility is necessary so that any disclosure regime—if required—would be proportionate and effective in achieving its purpose. However, the complexity of the voting process and its associated costs will certainly be taken into consideration in determining how provisions exercising this power might be shaped—if, indeed, it is decided ultimately to exercise it—and it is possible that this will lead to a disclosure regime which focuses more on voting instructions than on the actual votes cast. Amendment No. A256B would deem an institution to have met its disclosure obligation where it takes reasonable steps to ensure that its agent has made the appropriate disclosures. Underlying this is the principle of avoiding excessive compliance costs for an institution where its agent has been tasked with making the appropriate disclosure. We support this principle. Discussion of what steps are reasonably required to ensure compliance with the disclosure obligations will be an important consideration in determining the final shape of any mandatory disclosure regime, again if one is required. However, I must emphasise again the importance of leaving the scope of the power as it is at this stage. It is important to give due consideration to the other elements of the package at the time that the power is used, and cutting down on the flexibility of the power now would be premature. If it is decided in due course to proceed to establish a statutory disclosure regime, there would of course be full consultation and a cost-benefit analysis to make sure that any final regime was proportionately and properly targeted. I hope, therefore, that the noble Lord will withdraw the amendment.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
681 c71-2GC 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Disclosure of information Company law Companies Costs EU law Insolvency Regulation Shares Shareholders Reviews Impact assessments
Legislation
Company Law Reform Bill (HL) 2005-06
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk