Proceeding contribution from Lord Macdonald of Tradeston (Labour) in the House of Lords on Friday, 16 June 2006. It occurred during Debate and Debate on select committee report on BBC: Charter.
BBC: Charter
My Lords, I am pleased to follow the right reverend prelate the Bishop of Manchester and his thoughtful contribution, particularly since I spent 18 happy years in Salford, broadcasting to the north-west, and I wish him well in his campaign. I want to focus on how the draft charter and framework agreement might reposition BBC policy towards programming, categorised as covering ““religion and other beliefs””. I declare an interest as chairman of the Parliamentary Humanist Group. The Communications Act 2003 gives the BBC a duty to make programmes on ““religion and other beliefs””. The Minister in your Lordships’ House responsible for broadcasting in 2003, the noble Lord, Lord McIntosh of Haringey, made it clear that those ““other beliefs”” included non-religious beliefs. I congratulate my noble friend Lord Davies of Oldham and the DCMS for the way that they have handled this always fraught process of charter renewal and I pay tribute to the thorough reviews of the BBC charter conducted by the noble Lord, Lord Fowler, and other noble Lords on the Select Committee. In particular, I welcome their recommendation that,"““the BBC should review its programme output to ensure that it complies with the Communications Act 2003 by providing services of a suitable quality and range dealing with religion and other beliefs””." Your Lordships’ committee calls for the ““objective portrayal”” of"““different religions and other belief systems””." It supports"““a wide definition of broadcasting about religion and other beliefs””," and is"““eager to see more high quality, innovative and thought-provoking programmes emerging from the BBC Religion and Ethics Department””." All are commendable and easily achieved aims, given the BBC’s great resources and expertise in programme production across all areas. However, there must be a concern over the commitment of the BBC Religion and Ethics Department to deliver on what I perceive to be its duty under the 2003 Act to give appropriate coverage to ““other beliefs””, particularly those non-religious beliefs and alternative practices and ethics that daily guide the lives of many millions of secular British citizens, and not just signed-up humanists. Incidentally, your Lordships’ review remarks rather pointedly on the relatively small membership of the British Humanist Association. Our Parliamentary Humanist Group numbers just about 5 per cent of parliamentarians—perhaps three dozen Members of your Lordships’ House to date—admittedly, not a lot. We non-believers traditionally have been an ill-defined and diffident lot, but, across both Houses of Parliament, I have no doubt that we could probably be numbered in hundreds, reflecting in rough proportion the general public who we all strive to represent. Polling suggests that at least 15 per cent, perhaps up to 25 per cent, of the public is not religious, with higher percentages of young people. Whichever way you reckon, the views of the BBC’s constituency of licence-paying non-believers merits more serious consideration of its beliefs about how best to lead a good life in a decent society. Humanists make no claim to represent all non-religious people. However, the British Humanist Association took it upon itself to interrogate the BBC on the interpretation of its duty to other beliefs, following the Communications Act 2003. The BBC’s response is that most existing coverage of ethical or moral issues includes a secular, scientific or technological perspective, as does its history and arts programming. In addition, it argues, atheists such as Jonathan Miller and Richard Dawkins presented series on religion, and others such as Philip Pullman and Polly Toynbee appear on programmes such as ““Heaven and Earth””. That is true up to a point, but, surely, the secular characteristics that inform so much programming are simply the shared assumptions of mature, educated democracies, which, at best, use reason and evidence as the foundation of sensible public discourse. As our religious colleagues would be the first to argue, there is another important dimension beyond that—of values, morality, spirituality and the framework of belief. And it is in that dimension of programming that non-religious, or counter-religious output, is not commissioned systematically in proportion, nor scheduled in parallel, with the large and steady flow of explicitly religious programming across the BBC schedules. I am sure that the BBC could point to many very professional, irreligious programme makers happily filling the so-called ““God slots””. I speak from experience, having first appeared on television some 40 years ago in one of the first religious series, on ITV’s ““Sunday Break””. Subsequently, I had at different times executive responsibility for religious programming at both Granada and Scottish Television. As a non-believer, I worked effectively with my panels of religious advisers from the major Churches and, at times, produced what my clerical friends judged to be reasonably ambitious and successful series—some about ethics, some about social action, some even investigative and exposing paranormal nonsense or fraudulent faith healers. Religious or godless, we seemed to have much in common when it came to right and wrong. So, my argument is that religious and alternative ethical programming can and should co-exist in proper proportion. Turning to the draft framework agreement and the new Royal Charter, I look to both to take forward the BBC’s duties to ““other beliefs””: through the BBC’s remit to sustain citizenship and civil society and increasing understanding through accurate and impartial analysis of events and ideas; through its remit to promote education and learning; and through its remit to reflect all our communities, promoting awareness of different cultures and alternative viewpoints—always having regard, as the draft framework agreement re-states, to"““the importance of reflecting different religions and other beliefs””." A sad truth about television is that in the competitive clamour of news, drama and entertainment, religious programming has lacked status and, indeed, viewers. In truth, some of the programming has been formulaic and perhaps anodyne. That in part explains why, in most recent audience surveys, viewers still put religious output near the bottom of their programme preferences. However, as you will hear the Churches argue, religion is playing an increasingly important role in public life and it is certainly true that many people are increasingly dismayed by the aspects of religious militancy that challenge the values and practices of our democratic, secular societies. That is all the more reason to widen the debate on belief—and in that I hope I would make common cause with the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Manchester. Therefore, I look to the Government to resist the argument that what is needed is yet more of the same religious programming. Religion’s role in society is too important to be left only to believers inside or outside the BBC. Those millions of British citizens with no religious commitment, but often with strongly held alternative beliefs, have a right to speak in the same spaces on the same issues as established faiths. We, too, have profound beliefs on how life should be lived, which are well-rooted in ancient belief and hard-won over recent centuries—often in the face of clerical resistance. However, as we have proved in Britain, with the help of public service broadcasting, this can and should be a respectful engagement. The BBC can ensure that. The purpose of"““Sustaining citizenship and civil society””" will better be served by getting beyond the exclusive inter-faith dialogues, beyond narrow, shared certainties, to engage with those whose ethical values can surely be aligned to the many positive, tolerant and humane activities of the faith communities in Britain. In conclusion, I look in good faith to the new BBC Trust and the new BBC executive board to widen engagement and so enhance the vigour of debate and its range of religious and ethical opinion through the proper and sensible interpretation of the Communications Act, the Royal Charter and the new framework agreement.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 683 c441-4
- Session
- 2005-06
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords chamber
- Subjects
- Accountability BBC Costs Competition Digital broadcasting Channel Four Television Finance Fees and charges Governing bodies Public appointments Parliamentary scrutiny Political impartiality Public service broadcasting Reviews Royal charters Television licences
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2024-04-21 12:38:47 +0100
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_330289
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_330289
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_330289