Proceeding contribution from Lord Trimble (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Monday, 21 May 2007. It occurred during Debate on bill on Justice and Security (Northern Ireland) Bill.
Justice and Security (Northern Ireland) Bill
My Lords, I beg to move, as an amendment to Motion A, Motion A1, at end to insert, ““but do propose Amendments Nos. 3B to 3D to Commons Amendment No. 3A””. I was very pleased when the Minister in this House accepted the new clause that I tabled a few weeks ago. I particularly appreciated the comments that he made in doing so when he referred to the new clause having four main elements, two of which comprised ““shalls”” and two of which comprised ““mays””. He noted that there was a balance between what the inspector would be required to do and those matters on which he would have discretion. He said that parliamentary draftsmen would look at these matters and, if they felt that the drafting could be improved, would do so. I had, and have, no difficulty with parliamentary draftsmen looking at these matters and tidying them up. I shall not fuss about the form of matters; it is the substance which is important to me. However, I regret to say that I believe there has been a change of substance here. I noted that when Motion A was being considered in another place, the Minister, Mr Goggins, said: "““The Government amendment is therefore consistent with the approach taken in existing legislation relating to the chief inspector's other inspection functions””.—[Official Report, Commons, 10/5/07; col. 330.]" Would that it were. The amendment has changed one of the ““shalls”” that I had in the original new clause to a ““may””. I refer to the ““shall”” that imposed upon the inspector of criminal justice a duty to inspect schemes. Under this amendment that has now become a discretion, which I do not believe is a step in the right direction. It is instructive to look at the powers and functions of the chief inspector under the existing legislation. This is referred to in the Government’s amendment. Section 46 of the Justice (Northern Ireland) Act 2002, headed, ““Functions of Chief Inspector””, begins: "““(1) The Chief Inspector must carry out inspections of the following organisations””." It does not say ““may”” or ““shall””, but ““must””. The organisations listed include the Police Service of Northern Ireland, Forensic Science Northern Ireland, the State Pathologist’s Department, the Public Prosecution Service for Northern Ireland, the Probation Board for Northern Ireland, the Northern Ireland Prison Service and the Justice Board. All these things must be inspected, but when we come to community restorative justice schemes, the Government prefer ““may””. I refer to the publication of reports. Subsection (5)(b) in the Government’s Amendment No. 3A refers toSection 49 of the Justice (Northern Ireland) Act 2002. The amendment states that, "““section 49(2) to (4) of the Justice (Northern Ireland) Act 2002 … shall apply in relation to the report””." It leaves out Section 49(1), which states: "““The Chief Inspector must report to the Secretary of State on each inspection and review carried out by him””." Against the background of those mandatory requirements in the 2002 Act, I found great difficulty in sympathising with the argument put by the Minister. If it is a matter of form, I am not concerned with it; it is a question of the substance. The substance with regard to the other functions of the criminal justice legislation under the 2002 Act is to put a duty on the inspector to inspect, and to put a duty on him to report with regard to each inspection. If that is the function and the duty of the inspector with regard to all those other matters that he has to look at, why should those responsibilities be less with regard to community restorative justice schemes?The other functions that the inspector is inspecting—the police, the prosecution service, the juvenileboard, the probation board and all the rest of it—are carried out by professional persons whose knowledge and skill is known from their strong record. A duty is put on the inspector with regard to the inspection of those professional persons carrying out duties that they have carried out before in a responsible way. Here, we have community restorative justice schemes which, by and large, are going to be run by former paramilitaries—the guidelines adopted by the Northern Ireland Office are designed to enable former paramilitaries to run them—yet with regard to them there will be a lesser requirement in terms of inspection and publication. That naturally gives me concern. I want to see community restorative justice schemes operating properly, and the only measure that we have to ensure that is the inspectorate. The inspectorate therefore should be operating with regard to community restorative justice schemes to the same standard and under the same duties as apply to the functions of the inspectorate generally. Moved, as an amendment to Motion A, Motion A1, at end to insert, ““but do propose Amendments Nos. 3B to 3D to Commons Amendment No. 3A””.—(Lord Trimble.)
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 692 c454-6
- Session
- 2006-07
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords chamber
- Subjects
- Administration of justice Northern Ireland Paramilitary forces Community restorative justice
- Legislation
- Justice and Security (Northern Ireland) Bill 2006-07
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2023-12-15 11:13:34 +0000
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_398268
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_398268
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_398268