Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Grant Shapps (Conservative) in the House of Commons on Wednesday, 23 May 2007. It occurred during Opposition day on Secretary of State for Health.


Secretary of State for Health

I shall try to adhere to your guidance, Mr. Deputy Speaker. If we are discussing the health service, it is important to acknowledge that extra money has been invested and some improvements made, particularly on waiting times. We then have to ask whether the money has been spent sensibly and whether we could get more from it by spending it more productively. One of the dangers of a debate like this is that we quickly descend into our own individual examples of exactly what is happening in our own local health economies and local hospitals. That sometimes misses the broader point, because it is always possible to find one example that proves or disproves a general rule, so I shall leave any comments about local matters until the end. What I want to say is that accountability within the health service is one of its great problems, despite the amount of money going into it. I suspect that we have all experienced the problem of taking an issue on behalf of a constituent to an acute health trust. It tells us that the matter is not its responsibility, but that of the commissioning agency, the primary care trust, which then says that it is a matter for the strategic health authority, now a regional body. The SHA proceeds to tell us that it is not a matter that it can deal with, because the Secretary of State needs to intervene. At that point, we contact the Secretary of State for Health, who tells us that it is a matter for the local health economy—[Hon. Members: ““Absolutely””]—so we have gone round in a huge circle. It is extremely difficult, in a system that almost deliberately seems to go out of its way to cause such confusion, ever to pin down exactly who is responsible or accountable for what is happening locally.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
460 c1376 
Session
2006-07
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Accountability Health NHS Ministers Department of Health Hewitt, Patricia
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk