Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (Crossbench) in the House of Lords on Wednesday, 12 December 2007. It occurred during Committee of the Whole House (HL) and Debate on bill on Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill [HL].


Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill [HL]

moved Amendment No. 66A: 66A: Clause 39, page 37, line 43, at beginning insert ““either the man was married to the woman at the time of his death and he and the woman were trying to conceive, or”” The noble Baroness said: This is a probing amendment, and I look forward to hearing a response and clarification from the Government. I preface my remarks with that, because I am not sure that we should debate at any great length the pros and cons of my amendment; I simply seek clarification to know where to go next. Clause 39(1)(b) is about whether, "““the creation of the embryo carried by W was brought about by using the sperm of a man after his death””," and so on. This will probably be called the Diane Blood amendment, so I shall call it that myself, because that is where the need for clarification comes from. In 1995 Mr Blood died of meningitis, and we have had a lot of legislation since. I fully acknowledge that taking sentences out of a judgment sometimes makes for an inappropriate quotation, but two passages leapt out at me from the judgment of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Woolf. The first is: "““The result is that in the ordinary way no preservation can take place unless the required written consents exist””." That related to the preservation of extracted sperm from the man. Secondly, the final paragraph states that: "““Our decision means that, unless fresh sperm are being used, there will always be a need for written consent which complies with the Schedule. It seems therefore that in future those who are responsible who for treating a man and a woman together should take the precaution of having the necessary consent, not only to storage but also to enable that treatment to continue if the man should have the misfortune to die before the sperm is sperm””." I fear that that last word might be a misprint on the website, and should be ““used””. That judgment related to the 1990 Act—the Act that we are looking to revise—hence my questions. In the Mental Capacity Act, we now have provision for an advanced statement of wishes, which, if properly recorded, must be considered when a best-interest decision is taken on a patient. I put ““married”” in the amendment because I felt that it was a clear, external demonstration of a commitment—one could assume a lifelong commitment—to provide a stable environment in which a couple would have children. Let us take a married couple who want to conceive and are having sex regularly, and it is clear that they are completely committed to each other and to having a child together. Maybe when they are advised to carry on trying, and to try certain times in the month and avoid others and so on, and that is clear to their GP, the man becomes ill and dies. They are fully aware that the woman could conceive and that, within a month, the man could be killed in a road accident. In that event, the advanced statement of wishes could or should be respected. The man could state that it would be deemed to be in his best interests as a person, should he become severely incapacitated, for his sperm to be withdrawn and stored so that the woman—at a future date, when she has recovered from the bereavement—could use his sperm rather than anyone else’s, if she so wishes and decides to go for infertility treatment. That would be lawful. The man’s sperm might already be held when he dies. According to the Bill, I understand that it would then be lawful to use that sperm, because all the consent forms would have been written. The other situation that could arise is, of course, that the bereaved woman still wishes to have a family on her own. She could go to an infertility clinic and might be accepted for donor sperm. For her, the rest of her family and the situation in which she finds herself, the sperm of her dead husband might be the material that is ideally wished to be used. It is in that spirit that I wanted to explore the matter. That is why I crafted the amendment as I did. I look forward to the Government’s reply. I have had advance notice, which I appreciate, that the noble Baroness, Lady Deech, will oppose the amendment, but I seek clarification. I beg to move.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
697 c283-5 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Disability Disclosure of information Data protection Civil partnerships Death Abortion Congenital abnormalities Fertility Human embryo experiments Donors Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority Ethics IVF Fathers Parents Parental responsibility Registration of births, deaths, marriages and civil partnerships Research
Legislation
Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill (HL) 2007-08
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk