Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord McKenzie of Luton (Labour) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 13 December 2007. It occurred during Debates on delegated legislation on Financial Assistance Scheme (Miscellaneous Amendments) Regulations 2007.


Financial Assistance Scheme (Miscellaneous Amendments) Regulations 2007

I shall review that question when we have seen what is covered in the report. The noble Lord will have to bear with us until it is published, which may or may not satisfy his quite proper detailed inquiry. To the extent that it does not, I shall undertake to be more specific on outstanding residual issues. I hope that that satisfies the noble Lord. Both noble Lords touched on the issue of the amount conceived by the Government to put into the scheme and the difference between core pension and what otherwise would have been pension entitlement. We should be clear that it was never conceived as a pension scheme; it was an income replacement proposal to deal with the challenges that individuals faced. There are difficult judgments within that, such as the net present value and total cost figures of where we are today, which are considerable sums of public expenditure. Those are the sorts of difficult judgments that being in government have to be faced and analysed. I have a feeling that I have answered most of the questions of the noble Lord, Lord Skelmersdale, but doubtless he will remind me if I have not. The noble Lord, Lord Oakeshott, referred to the vigil. I know that my colleague Mike O’Brien was there. I am pleased that the noble Lord has the T-shirt. I reiterate that whatever anger has been generated, the Government have always had great sympathy with the plight of individuals who have lost their pensions. In a sense it is easy to do that; it is just words. The challenge has been deciding what goes in place to support those people. That is the journey we have been on, and I hope that what comes out next week will be the end of that journey. The noble Lord asked about the difference between the 80 per cent and 90 per cent rate and what that would mean per year, and he referred to previous correspondence between us. In light of what the Prime Minister said at Question Time, it will be best to wait until next week. If it is not clear from that, certainly I can write further to the noble Lord. He asked whether I read Pensions Week. The answer is no but I shall put it on my reading list. I am still ploughing through the 1974 Second Reading of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act when Michael Foot was Secretary of State, as part of my understanding of my ministerial responsibilities. The noble Lord asked about administration and why it could not be dealt with by the PPF. There was a review last year of FAS administration, which looked explicitly at whether the PPF should administer FAS, and concluded that it should not. We need to look at that again to see how it can best be administered in the light of the Young report. I have not answered when next week it will happen; it is not within my gift. The usual channels have an influence on this, but it is not unreasonable that it will happen before the House rises. I do not think I am on my brief in saying that, but that would be reasonable and what we would want to achieve. Going back to the issue of administration, there have been challenges—certainly on cost. For the first year, which we are only part of the way through, we have seen the level of payments made by FAS far outstrips the costs. It took time to build up the IT infrastructure to get the systems in place to last us over many decades. It is now clear that the annual costs of that are way below the annual amounts that have been paid out. I hope that I have dealt with each of the questions that have been asked. There was a reference to Northern Rock and how quickly the Government acted. There is no parallel. For a start, the funding that went into Northern Rock was a loan and not a payment or inevitably a call on taxpayers’ money. However, the judgment was that the Government acted to avert a threat to the very stability of the financial system, which is why they acted as they did and with the speed with which they did. It is therefore not right to make that parallel.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
697 c199-200GC 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Civil partners Finance Financial assistance scheme Workplace pensions Pensions Widowed people
Legislation
Financial Assistance Scheme (Miscellaneous Amendments) Regulations 2007
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk