---

Criminal Evidence (Witness Anonymity) Bill

The hon. and learned Gentleman's amendment No. 22 proposes inserting the words"““assess the reasonableness of any fear alleged on the part of the witness or another person””" in clause 4(6). Is that because he does not believe that the ““reasonable fear”” that the clause as drafted refers to is an objective test—it seems to me that it is indeed an objective test for the court to decide—or because of the lack of a requirement for the court to assess it? I would have thought that in order to have regard to such a fear, one would have to assess it. I am therefore not convinced that his amendment adds anything, particularly if the Minister clarifies my understanding when she responds to the debate. Have I missed something in his argument?