---

Criminal Evidence (Witness Anonymity) Bill

The hon. and learned Gentleman has hit the question. My reading of the provision in other statute is that the test is objective. The fear is not deemed reasonable because a witness is nervous; rather, there is an objective test of whether the fear of that witness under the circumstances is, in the view of the court, reasonable. However, if the hon. and learned Gentleman, who is more learned than me by definition, feels that that is not clear enough—I think that he is saying that in his amendment—perhaps the Minister can provide some clarity in her response and make it clear that the test is an objective test, exactly as he wishes it to be.