Proceeding contribution from Ian Pearson (Labour) in the House of Commons on Wednesday, 14 January 2009. It occurred during Adjournment debate on Exchange Rate Policy.
Exchange Rate Policy
The hon. Gentleman is right that overall the sterling exchange rate index has declined by 25 per cent. in the past two years and by about 14 per cent. since the beginning of August 2008. Exchange rates fluctuate. He is also right that against the dollar, sterling has lost more than a fifth of its value in the past two years, and more than a quarter against the euro. International developments have affected other countries. The euro has lost about 8 per cent. of its value against the dollar since summer 2007 and the yen has lost about 17 per cent. The International Monetary Fund has stated:"““Foreign exchange markets have also been affected by heightened uncertainty about the safety and soundness of global financial assets and the impact of financial stress on economic performance.””" It should also be remembered that recent falls in sterling have come after a sustained period of sterling strength that lasted through the late 1990s and until long after the mid-point of this decade, so despite recent falls, we have had a decade in which the exchange rate has been historically stable overall. We shall continue to see exchange rate fluctuations in this country and with other countries' currencies as well. That is the nature of floating exchange rates. Let me say something about exchange rate policy. If we go back, as the hon. Gentleman did, to the post-war era and before, we can see that there have been a number of attempts, as he well knows, to control the exchange rate and, as a result, the UK economy as a whole, but those have been rarely without complication and mostly unsuccessful. For the first part of the post-war era, sterling belonged to the Bretton Woods system of fixed exchange rates. That arrangement ended in 1972. Through the '70s and '80s, which we remember well, there were various attempts to use the exchange rate as a policy instrument, including by having sterling shadow the Deutschmark. In 1990, sterling joined the exchange rate mechanism, which tied sterling within a target band against the euro in the hope that that would deliver low inflation for the UK economy. I do not need to rehearse the arguments about the UK's ignominious exit from the exchange rate mechanism to the hon. Gentleman or engage in political point scoring about that or, indeed, the record of previous Labour Governments when we had to devalue the pound. The one thing in his contribution with which I agreed was what he said about floating exchanges rates. He seemed to be a fan of floating exchange rates. Since September 1992, sterling has been allowed to float freely against other currencies. The Government's objective is a stable and competitive exchange rate in the medium term, consistent with meeting the inflation target. Our experience in economic policy making is that trying to target exchange rates is simply the wrong policy. The policy of inflation targeting has stood the UK in good stead over the most recent period. The Government's macro-economic framework includes a monetary framework that is designed to deliver low and stable inflation through the symmetrical inflation target. As the hon. Gentleman knows, the target is 2 per cent. at all times. Under that regime, the exchange rate is allowed to adjust to clear the market. Despite the major challenges presented by the global economy at present, the framework continues to serve us well and compares favourably with the outcome of the previous macro-economic policy approaches to inflation and growth that I have mentioned. Since 1997, inflation has averaged less than half what it averaged in the previous two decades, while growth has been stronger. Indeed, since 1997, the UK has had one of the lowest inflation rates in the G7; before 1997 it had one of the highest. There is no shortage of evidence on the other key strengths of the UK economy. I could point to the foreign direct investment as a percentage of our gross domestic product, which is the highest in the G7. The World Bank ranks the UK as the sixth best place to do business out of 181 countries in its ““Doing Business 2009”” report. There are clearly implications from a weaker exchange rate, both for prices and for volumes of goods and services in the economy, and the hon. Gentleman mentioned some of them. He also mentioned Charles Bean, the deputy governor of the Bank of England with responsibility for monetary policy, and I, too, should like to quote him:"““We've had the best part of a 20 per cent. depreciation of sterling over the past year, which is pretty hefty. Now, obviously the external climate has worsened, but that very considerable stimulus from the exchange rate should also help to pull the economy out of its slow period.””" In addition to the automatic stabilisers, a floating exchange rate, combined with the Government's overall macro-economic policy, offers a sensible strategy to help the UK economy during difficult economic times. I have to make the point that has been made elsewhere about the decisions and judgments that the Government made in the pre-Budget report and previously about giving a fiscal stimulus to the UK economy during these difficult economic times. The fact that countries across the world have decided to introduce similar packages of support indicates the strength of our position. It is simply the right thing to do. I also refer the hon. Gentleman to the comments that the Governor of the Bank of England made recently when giving evidence to the Treasury Committee. He rightly expressed concerns:"““If sterling falls far enough, this will be a concern and it will have an impact on inflation...Just as the…Dollar fell very sharply over a period, it's not surprising that we're seeing some fall in sterling's effective exchange rate; and that can be a helpful part of the rebalancing, provided it doesn't threaten our ability to meet the inflation target. So it's something that we keep a very careful eye on and we certainly have no wish to see it fall particularly sharply. But I think we have to accept that some fall back from the level where it was…in the summer of 2007 is probably an inevitable part of the rebalancing that's going on.””" A weaker exchange rate, all other things being equal, makes our exports more competitive than they would otherwise be, but also risks higher prices. That is one of the many global issues that policy makers have to consider in the current challenging environment. The hon. Gentleman and I simply part ways in our fundamental economic analysis of how the macro-economic policy framework should be designed and how the exchange rate fits into the regime. If he wants to come back and suggest that inflation targeting is not the right policy and, as his party does, that a fiscal stimulus during a global financial crisis in which the European economy and the United States are already in recession is not the right thing to do, his party needs to set out more coherent arguments as to why that is the case.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 486 c136-8WH
- Session
- 2008-09
- Chamber / Committee
- Westminster Hall
- Subjects
- Business Economic situation Prices Sterling Exchange rates World economy
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2023-12-05 22:00:10 +0000
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_518511
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_518511
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_518511