Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Labour) in the House of Lords on Wednesday, 18 March 2009. It occurred during Debate on select committee report on EU: Emissions Trading System (EUC Report).


EU: Emissions Trading System (EUC Report)

It is a pleasure to respond to the committee’s excellent report. I commend my noble friend and members of the committee on it. I agree with him that the Government’s response shows that there is not much between us; we all broadly share the same philosophy, and many of the questions that noble Lords have raised are the very issues that the Government are grappling with in our negotiations in Europe and internationally. This has been a good debate. I share my noble friend’s enjoyment of taking part in debates in the Moses Room. Indeed, as a refugee from the Marine and Coastal Access Bill, I wish that we could debate in the Moses Room day after day after day. I agree with my noble friend Lord Sewel that, although the report was written in the lead-up to the negotiations for the agreement reached in December last year, the substantive comments have been as apposite to the situation today and in the lead-up to Copenhagen as they were before Christmas. The report is as relevant as when it was first produced. The noble Baroness, Lady Sharp, said that at its heart, emissions trading is simple. Indeed it is, but the reality is that it is a very complex procedure. The noble Baroness, Lady Wilcox, and I share a strong feeling that the language used by governments and NGOs in the whole arena of climate change seems designed to create a barrier between the experts and the public. Over the next few years, as people begin to understand what climate change really means and what we have to do to combat it, we will have to sort out the language. Who understands what the words "mitigation and adaptation" mean? The trading scheme itself is very difficult for anyone unless they do what noble Lords on the committee have done, which is to spend many hours and days learning to understand it. This is a major challenge if we are to win public support for the changes that need to be made. Let us be frank. The reason it has proved to be so difficult to negotiate a really effective emissions trading scheme in Europe is because of the fears felt by Governments about the impact of going for a tight scheme on their industries, jobs and the public. While collectively I think we can regard ourselves as inside the climate change tent, in the lead-up to Copenhagen we need to think carefully about how we will manage communications and take the public with us. If we cannot do that, we are not going to pass the test set for us by the noble Lord, Lord Teverson, of promoting the critical importance of making this system work. The noble Lord, Lord Teverson, said that the ETS is the major tool in our armoury, so we have to make it work. However, noble Lords suggested that phase 1 had been a failure. My noble friend Lord Giddens and the noble Baronesses, Lady Sharp and Lady Wilcox, also made that point. It is clear that the market was overallocated and, in the euphemism of Europe, the 2005-07 phase of the ETS was also intended as a "learning period" prior to the Kyoto commitment. Perhaps that is the softly-softly approach described by the noble Lord, Lord Cameron. We are where we are, and the really important issue is whether we have learnt the lessons taught by the difficulties encountered in phase 1 to translate, at least in terms of practice, into phase 2 and, it is hoped, into the outcome of phase 3. In phase 2 the Government will auction 7 per cent of allowances, one of the highest levels of auctioning in the EU. We have held one auction so far, and from now on we will be auctioning every two months. Perhaps I may write to the noble Lord, Lord Teverson, and other members of the Committee because I have extensive details of how the first auction went. It was oversubscribed, which gives us confidence for the future integrity of the system. As I say, I have some interesting information about it that I am happy to circulate. That takes us to phase 3. It is a fact that we were able to conclude an agreement in December. Although noble Lords have expressed disappointment with some aspects of it, it was by no means assured that we would even reach an agreement. At many moments it appeared to be touch and go, which explains some of the compromises that have had to be made. We cannot run away from that. The noble Viscount, Lord Ullswater, talked about the current economic climate, and he was absolutely right to do so. But the state of the economic climate was used by many countries in the negotiations to argue that the downturn justified postponing action on climate change until stability returns. To accept that argument would be an utter disaster. Although there is some disappointment about certain aspects of what was agreed in December, the fact is that an agreement was reached. That agreement puts us in a much better position for phase 3 than we are in for the current phase. We see a more rigorous approach to setting the cap on emissions; it is set at a much more ambitious level, and there is a large increase in auctioning. Several noble Lords commented on auctioning. I have every sympathy with the points raised, but the fact is that at least 60 per cent of EU ETS allowances will be auctioned by 2020. In phase 2, by our reckoning, only about 3 per cent of allowances are being auctioned across the EU. Our goal for the EU ETS is for 100 per cent auctioning in the long term. We share the committee’s goal on that, but I cannot underestimate the difficulties that we have had in negotiating the auctioning level that has been agreed. We must carry on arguing on that. The noble Lord, Lord Teverson, is right about free allocation: it will not end until 2027 in the revised directive, but will be revised after Copenhagen, assuming that we are successful. We must ensure that any free allocations are fully justified. Aviation will be included in the EU ETS from 2012, but not shipping. I understand that if nothing is agreed internationally on shipping at Copenhagen, the European Commission will put forward a proposal by 2011 on the inclusion of shipping in the EU ETS, because clearly it is very important that that should happen. What about the non-traded sector? The package included an agreed effort-sharing decision that sets targets for reductions in the sectors of member states and economies not covered by the EU ETS. For the UK, that would mean a reduction by 2020 of 16 per cent from the 2005 levels, achieved mainly in transport and heating. It is then left to member states to set out policy measures to meet those targets. In the case of the UK, that is governed by the Climate Change Act, the Energy Act and the renewable energy strategy. One way that we will do that is through carbon budgets, which will be set for government departments. Departments will then have to take responsibility for the particular sector of the economy where carbon emissions take place. We see that as a way to bear down on emissions not covered by the ETS. We are working very hard across government at the moment on the development of carbon budgets. I believe that that will be a very important tool in the UK’s armoury. Let me give an example of that: agriculture. Because of the importance of the agricultural sector, which several noble Lords referred to, it is perfectly possible that one of my departments, Defra, will have to take responsibility for a reduction of emissions in that sector. Frankly, that could be very challenging indeed for Defra. Speaking as a DECC Minister, I am delighted that it is that department which is to face the challenge. I took part, appropriately enough, in a seminar at London Zoo about four weeks ago, where Defra had called together experts from the agriculture/farming sector to discuss how emissions could be reduced. We had very good representation from farming interests, and there was a great deal of encouragement. We are committed to exploring the potential scope and feasibility of a market mechanism to enable the trading of greenhouse gas reductions from agriculture, forestry and land management. We are very much focused on the points that have been raised by a number of noble Lords. I have heard the noble Lord, Lord Teverson, speak very eloquently before on the question of CDM, when I came in at a late stage on the Climate Change Act. I entirely understand where he is coming from. On the other hand, CDM provides valuable financial flows to developing countries. At heart, the question is the integrity of the system. Noble Lords have essentially said that we have to ensure that monitoring and enforcement are of the highest order. I and the Government agree with that, and we will be working with our EU partners to address those problems. In general, that leads to the point raised by my noble friends Lord Giddens and Lord Brooke about monitoring. I will go on to talk about the issues that were raised about the FSA. Clearly, unless we have confidence that the system is properly monitored and properly enforced, it will not have credibility. It is a tremendous challenge for all of us to ensure that the system has credibility. My noble friend Lord Sewel and other noble Lords mentioned carbon leakage, which is something that we have to tackle very seriously. Because of the need to tackle it, it raises concern about the directive’s provision to allocate allowances for free to those installations proven to be at significant risk of carbon leakage. We are concerned that the directive provides for rather more sectors to be deemed at risk of carbon leakage than appears justified by the available evidence. I am not sure that I am providing as much comfort here as noble Lords would ideally wish me to provide. I canprovide recognition that this is an important matter on which we will continue to have to work with our European colleagues. A number of noble Lords have raised the issue of the carbon price. It has gone up a bit; it currently stands at €12.50. When I was being briefed for an Oral Question two weeks ago—this did not come up, but it might have done—it was about €9. It is very much lower than it was only a short period ago. There are two points that I want to make. Of course, I accept the question about long-term investment. The noble Lord, Lord Browne, and my noble friend Lord Brooke talked about the considerations in a boardroom in terms of carbon pricing and what factor it bears. They both suggested that at the moment the answer is not a lot; certainly not in terms of making long-term investment decisions. Clearly, the volatility in price has not helped that, nor has the current economic crisis that we face. One of the questions is the extent to which it is still early days. As the trading system matures, companies may become more used to it and it may well factor into their decisions more; we must certainly hope so. We do not favour caps; in answer to the noble Lord, Lord Teverson, we prefer it to be a market-based mechanism. We will have to monitor the position, but where 2020 is concerned it is important to remember that the commitment, the ETS cap on emissions, is geared to deliver a 21 per cent reduction by 2025, and that has to be delivered regardless of the carbon price. Clearly, the carbon price has an impact on the decisions and the economics that will need to be addressed, but we will hold fast to the cap itself. On regulation, my noble friend Lord Brooke raised the fact that the European Commission is looking at whether we need greater regulation of the market to avoid the kind of manipulation that he spoke about. This is traded on a regulated market by the FSA. It is equivalent to other commodity markets. Obviously the role of the FSA in general has come under considerable scrutiny, but I have no evidence to suggest that the FSA has not been and is not able to discharge that responsibility effectively. On the question of a fiscal audit, one accepts the need for additional policies, including regulation, to complement the emissions trading system. We are looking to Her Majesty’s Treasury to keep us on track to ensure that the most effective balance and incentives are in place, and we will be ever vigilant on this. I turn to the issue of a global market and the links between the regional trading systems. My noble friend Lord Sewel and the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, raised the important problem of the differences between carbon pricing in different regional schemes. There is no doubt that where different regional schemes have different prices, that will cause difficulties in linking schemes. Our overall strategy is to have similar prices and ensure similar amounts of effort in emission reduction. That is our aim in negotiating an agreement in Copenhagen, which I will come back to in a moment. On technology, innovation and a competitive market for this country, yes, we must promote innovation. We have funds; I am responsible for one called the environmental transformation fund, which is geared towards companies in the renewables sector that are near to market. Other funds are administered by other government departments, notably DIUS, but we know that there is more to be done and we need to integrate those funds more. The noble Lord, Lord Browne, took part in a summit on the low-carbon economy about two weeks ago. It became well known for green paint, but it was actually an interesting discussion with stakeholders about how we ensure, with the inevitability of a low-carbon economy, that this country takes advantage of it, that there is proper investment, that we use British skills and that we make the most of our expertise. That will lead into a low-carbon economy strategy that we will publish in the summer. Of course the Budget will soon be upon us; I cannot comment on what is in it, because I do not know, but I will ensure that the comments on fiscal stimulus that were made today are passed on to the Treasury for its consideration. I shall certainly not respond to the comment of the noble Lord, Lord Teverson, about how I shall spend the £8 billion in 2020, much as I should like to. I hope that I can reassure noble Lords as regards coal and CCS. In the December negotiations we successfully persuaded Europe to support CCS. Of course, it is unproven in terms of scale and there is no getting away from the fact that it is very expensive. However, we are committed to having a commercial-scale CCS project operational by 2014. We have a competition process, the pre-qualification stage of which finished in June 2008. We aim to issue the formal invitations to negotiate shortly. I very much take the point that if we can pull off CCS in this country, it will offer us great potential in terms of exporting our know-how and technology. There is huge potential there, which is why we are committed to CCS. A number of noble Lords said that they were beginning to doubt whether we can pull this off. We should just keep the faith for a little longer. The Government are committed to taking CCS forward. As I said, the competition process will go forward. The Government certainly recognise the importance of CCS alongside all the other developments in the energy sector, including new nuclear and the takeover of British Energy by EDF. Given the expressions of interest now coming forward from a number of other consortia to build new nuclear, there is huge potential there for this country. One can look back to the 1950s and ask what would have happened if Britain had stuck with peaceful nuclear energy. We missed that chance but we have a second chance and we have to ensure that we make the most of it. As the noble Lord, Lord Teverson, and other noble Lords suggested, a huge effort will be required to reach the renewables target, but we are committed to doing so. We think that we have the stimulus right although a lot more work needs to be carried out. However, we believe that our technical leadership will produce many spin-offs for this country, particularly in the marine area. So much is riding on Copenhagen. We are optimistic. The discussions of my right honourable friend the Prime Minister in Washington were paralleled by Ed Miliband’s discussions with senior members of the Administration. The Obama Administration has a very important role to play, but so, too, do the developing countries. My noble friend Lord Brooke made the important point that we will not get a deal simply by hectoring developing countries. We know that that is the case. I agree with him and other noble Lords who mentioned the need to incentivise. I agree that the road to Copenhagen may well be very rocky, but at heart I remain optimistic. All the signs are that, although it will be very tough, there is a determination on the part of many countries to reach agreement. That will be very important as regards the renewed targets that Europe will have to discuss. This has been a very good debate. It has informed the Government about some of the key matters that we still need to take forward and to monitor carefully. The committee’s report is excellent and is improved and enhanced by tonight’s debate. I am most grateful to all noble Lords for all their hard work and the contributions they made tonight. I hope that in a year’s time we will gather together to discuss the outcome of Copenhagen with a view to it being successful, and that the EU ETS will be seen as an important contribution to that which has credibility and integrity. As noble Lords have said, I hope above all that the outcome is that we reduce our emissions.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
709 c141-6GC 
Session
2008-09
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Allowances Climate change Auctions Carbon capture and storage Enforcement EU emissions trading scheme Pollution control Prices Regulation Renewable energy Carbon emissions Greenhouse gas emissions
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk