Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Davies of Oldham (Labour) in the House of Lords on Wednesday, 25 March 2009. It occurred during Debate on bill on Corporation Tax Bill.


Corporation Tax Bill

My Lords, this Bill rewrites certain basic provisions such as the charge to corporation tax and provisions used by companies in computing their income. The main aim is to make the legislation clearer, better structured and easier to use than the source legislation, which is often dense and difficult to follow. The Bill has been produced by Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs Tax Law Rewrite Project. It is the first of two Bills that will rewrite corporation tax. The second will be introduced later this year, along with another which will rewrite international and other provisions, some of which apply for the purposes of both income tax and corporation tax. The work follows the success of the project’s previous Acts which rewrote the capital allowances and income tax legislation. I should explain that the Bill has been certified as a money Bill. It was introduced into Parliament in another place at the beginning of last December. Under the special procedures applying to tax law rewrite Bills, the substantive debate on Second Reading was held in Committee. The Bill then passed to a Joint Committee of the two Houses, where it was considered on 27 January. The Joint Committee included among its members the noble Lord, Lord Goodhart, and my noble friend Lady Goudie. I am grateful to them for their efforts in scrutinising the Bill, and to Sir Peter Viggers MP who chaired the Committee. The Bill then passed back to the House of Commons for its Third Reading and is now before us for its remaining stages, which the rules say can be taken in one day. It is beyond the remit of the project to make any significant changes in tax policy, so it takes great care to preserve the effects of the legislation. It can, however, make very minor agreed changes; for example, to remove ambiguity, repeal obsolete material or correct minor, unintended anomalies. To ensure that any changes made are within the remit of the project, they are considered during an extensive, detailed and thorough consultation process involving the project’s consultative committee, whose members are drawn from the main tax professional and business representative bodies. The work is overseen by an independent steering committee, chaired by the noble Lord, Lord Newton of Braintree, whom I am pleased to see in his place and who will contribute to our proceedings a little later. It includes Members from both Houses, the judiciary, business and consumer groups and the accountancy and legal professions. The extensive consultation process that I mentioned involved publication for public comment of papers containing almost all the clauses in the Bill, and the Bill was also published in draft form for another round of consultation. In addition, groups of private sector specialists met the project to consider the detail of some of the more complex provisions so that the views of those who are the main users of the legislation were taken fully into account. Throughout the process, proposed minor changes in the law were specifically drawn to the attention of consultees; no minor changes in the law were included in this Bill without the considered approval of both the project’s committees. The Joint Committee of both Houses heard oral evidence from members of the Tax Law Rewrite Project team. It considered and accepted all the government amendments to the Bill, all of which it agreed were of a minor, technical nature. The Joint Committee concluded that the Bill is a welcome clarification of the existing law and, as a result, it will be easier to use and more accessible to Parliament, the judiciary, informed professionals, business people and other users of the legislation. It was satisfied that the changes of the law in the Bill are of very minor significance. The success of the project in improving the accessibility of the legislation to users has been borne out by independent market research, which showed that in the main, users of rewritten legislation warmly welcomed it. It was seen to be of particular help to those newly entering the profession. Consultees have also been positive about the project’s work. It would be wrong of me to conclude without paying tribute to everyone who has taken part in this important work. There are many consultees who have given their time and have used their considerable expertise to consider the detail of the rewritten clauses. As with all rewrite Bills, tax professionals who provide expert comment already understand the legislation and, therefore, have the least to gain from the rewritten provisions. Their selfless contribution to the consultation process for the benefit of the wider range of tax professionals who use the legislation is therefore particularly welcome. We owe a particular debt to the noble Lord, Lord Newton, for his service as chairman of the steering committee and to the members of both the project’s committees for their expert input and guidance. This is an extremely worthwhile project with a track record that shows that it makes our direct tax legislation more modern, clearer and easier to use. The Bill maintains the high standards achieved in the project’s previous Acts and will make the legislation more accessible to Parliament, the tax professions, business and the judiciary. I commend it to the House.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
709 c721-3 
Session
2008-09
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Companies Business Corporation tax Competition Reform Taxation Tax rates and bands
Legislation
Corporation Tax Bill 2008-09
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk