Proceeding contribution from Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 28 April 2009. It occurred during Debate on bill and Committee proceeding on Perpetuities and Accumulations Bill [HL].
Perpetuities and Accumulations Bill [HL]
I thank the Minister very much for explaining a complex, technical Bill and for the new procedure under which we are to operate, in which we are, in racing terms, the first out of the traps. I begin by declaring interests—charitable interests which are on the Register. Perhaps in the light of the subject matter that we are discussing, I should draw the Committee’s attention to the fact that I am president of the National Council of Voluntary Organisations, which of course has some interest in our proceedings. That having been said, I am not a lawyer, and I shall leave the legal aspects to my noble friend Lord Kingsland, who has already forgotten more law than I will ever know, and focus instead on one or two practical implications that could be tweaked in the Bill and which may represent an improvement. As I said, I welcome this new approach, because speeding up the modernisation of legislation is very important. I had a bit of a baptism of fire on this when dealing with what was originally the Company Law Reform Bill—on which I had the honour of representing the party on the Front Bench—which became the Companies Act 2006. As one dug into that, one saw how the 2006 Bill was going to amend the 2004 Act, which amended the 1989 Act, the 1985 Act and, in a few cases, as far back as the 1929 Act. The archaeological layers meant, as the Minister said in his opening remarks, that often provisions have become entirely dislocated from the real world and completely incomprehensible other than to the specialist. We were able, thanks to the Government’s good offices, including the Minister’s colleague, the noble Lord, Lord Sainsbury, to expand the Bill to bring everything into one place in a much bigger Bill—a 1,300 clause Bill. There were a couple of exceptions, including community interest companies, which we shall of course touch on later in our debates. In so far as this is part of the same process, I welcome it. The Minister was unduly modest when he explained the history of the Bill. I understand that the initial consultation on this Bill took place in 1993. It was the subject of a Law Commission report in 1998, a constitutional affairs department report in 2002, more consultation in 2008 and now, 16 years on, we have the Bill. That shows that there is a need to speed up the procedure. I turn to the Bill itself. My first point concerns the issue of perpetuities. Obviously, I find perpetuity a complex issue, given concepts such as "lives in being". I ask for one clarification. I hope that the Bill team will forgive me when I say that when I read the Explanatory Notes trying to unravel the matter, I got to paragraph 6 on page 2. The fourth sentence says: ""The perpetuity period will be the life of A plus 21 years, measured from the date of X’s death"." Should it not read, ""at the date of X’s death"" rather than, ""from the date of X’s death"?" "From" indicates a continuum; "at" represents a point in time. This is a single point of measurement. I would be grateful if the Minister could confirm that. If I am wrong, it merely shows that perpetuities are even more complicated than I thought they were. Specifically, I welcome the extension of the fixed perpetuity period to 125 years from 80 years in Clause 5. Clearly, we want as little complexity as possible. The more time that is offered in terms of the period, the greater time there is to sort out any difficulties that may arise. Therefore, the principle of Clause 5 is greatly to be welcomed. However, there is a problem with Clause 2 on exceptions to the rule’s application. This concerns successive gifts to a charity. For example, charity A receives a gift but is unable, does not wish to or cannot fulfil the conditions of the gift, and so the gift goes to charity B and so on. Paragraph 39 of the Explanatory Notes lays this out very clearly. The exception for successive charitable gifts arises because any gift to a charity, whether to a named charity such as the lifeboats or to an exclusively charitable purpose, fulfils what I understand is the legal requirement for certainty. Therefore, it does not matter if the charitable purpose alters, because it remains a charitable purpose. Clause 2 does not refer to the second of these gifts for charitable purposes, only to gifts to a charity in subsections (2) and (3). The definitions on page 17 of the Explanatory Notes state that a charity is: ""An organisation established for charitable purposes only"." The 1964 Act allowed gifts for charitable purposes to be excluded from perpetuities. Therefore, when we consider the Bill in more detail, I hope that the Government will think again about this because it represents a narrowing of the way in which perpetuities operate. In this highly technical area there may be an answer to this question, but a simple amendment to the relevant subsections of Clause 2 would enable us to address this apparent narrowing. My second point concerns accumulations. Although we welcome making the accumulations rule much more straightforward and comprehensible, the charitable sector is concerned about the default provision of 21 years for charitable trusts. The Minister made clear in his opening remarks that there is an opportunity in Clause 14(2) for this to be set aside by a court or the Charity Commission. I accept that. It is also true that charitable trusts will probably be used less frequently in the future because we now have community interest companies and charitable incorporated organisations under the Charities Act 2006. Therefore, the trust structure may be used less in the future. Nevertheless, some people may wish to use trusts. I also accept that it will apply only going forward, not going back, although paragraph 25 at the top of page 6 of the Explanatory Notes states: ""Accordingly existing trust instruments and wills, that is, those taking effect before commencement, will generally not be affected by the Bill"." As I say, I am not a lawyer, but when I see words such as "generally" I begin to wonder what they mean in reality. I think that we should be doing everything that we can to encourage philanthropic endeavour, and this 21-year rule is an unduly heavy and inflexible sledgehammer. I will illuminate the argument with three brief examples. Trusts may have what are known as wasting assets. The wasting assets could be in two particular forms. There will be leaseholds, where the trust’s only asset is the lease of a property with an expiry date. When the lease comes to an end, the property reverts to the original owner; the trust no longer has any asset or any income and therefore will have to cease its operations. In such circumstances, it surely would be appropriate for the trust to be converting income to capital in the latter years of those leases in order to provide for endowment to enable it to carry on its original purposes. Many of these leases will run for longer than 21 years; they may be 99 years. This comes to its sharpest point on things such as copyright. I think it was Westminster School that benefited enormously from the endowment of AA Milne’s copyright on the Winnie the Pooh books. While Westminster School had a sufficiently large endowment to be able to avoid converting income to capital, because it had other capital endowment of its own, a charity with a single asset which was a valuable copyright would find, as the copyright began to run out, that it had to either cease operation or convert income to capital to provide a sum of money to enable it to continue operations. My Oxford college, being a poor college of relatively modern foundation, had at one time great hopes of getting the Reverend W Awdry’s Thomas the Tank Engine books as he was a member of the college, but unfortunately it was unrequited in the end. Wasting assets is one thing. Secondly, there is building up the sum endowed. The Minister and I in our different ways might decide that we wish to set up a charitable trust for a purpose that we feel is very worthwhile, and we get proper charitable permission but, being men of modest means, we can put only a smallish sum of capital in. We decide that during the rest of our lives, to have a decent sum of money for its future operation of our trust, we will roll up all the income and keep it in the capital so that there is a bigger pot for the trustees to work on after our death. The Minister and I—I think I am a few years ahead of the Minister—have a reasonable hope of passing 21 years, and therefore we would find that the rule as presently drafted would impact on us. That is a mistake because anything that encourages people to set up trusts and to accumulate income and build up the sum during a lifetime seems to me to be entirely sensible. Under the present rules you can do that, because the life of a settlor is the limit on accumulations at present. Lastly, and perhaps most importantly, there is what I call the "total return" approach to investment management. Historically, people have considered the return on their investment as being two parts—a flow of capital gain and a flow of income. The income comes from dividends and interest on bonds, and the capital gain comes from the increase in asset values. In recent years, those two streams have become increasingly co-mingled. They have become co-mingled because tax rates for private individuals have become much the same and therefore whether you took it as income or capital gains does not really matter, and because of the emergence of the new asset classes, such as private equity, where there is no income, only capital gains. Therefore, the total return concept of investment management has emerged. If you are looking for a 10 per cent return, you do not really mind whether it is 10 per cent capital gain or 10 per cent income, or some mixture of the two. I am concerned that in the way that we are currently looking at the Bill, with a 21-year life, some charitable trusts will find that the total return concept actually begins to work against the efficient operation of their investment management. I have already accepted that Clause 14(2) provides a let-out. We are trying to work to a situation where we have certainty and where a philanthropist knows what he or she can do. It may be that you can hope that the court or the Charity Commission will deal with you kindly, but we could try to increase that certainty by providing something a little less inflexible than the present approach. It is bureaucratic. I also think that it brings the Charity Commission into an invidious position of having to make value judgments about the readiness and appropriateness of rolling up income and converting it to capital. I conclude by welcoming the Bill’s general approach. I have raised a couple of points which I hope the Government will consider and reflect on as we work through the Bill. The Charity Commission’s strategic plan for 2008-11 gives it six tasks, two of which are to be innovative and responsive. I hope that the Government can be innovative and responsive as regards these questions.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 710 c4-8GC
- Session
- 2008-09
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords Grand Committee
- Subjects
- Assets Charitable trusts Copyright Leasehold Gifts and endowments Income Law Commission Property transfer Property law Property Taxation Trusts Wills
- Legislation
- Perpetuities and Accumulations Bill (HL) 2008-09
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2024-04-22 02:20:16 +0100
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_550882
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_550882
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_550882