Proceeding contribution from Lord Glentoran (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 1 December 2009. It occurred during Debate on bill on Northern Ireland Assembly Members Bill [HL].
Northern Ireland Assembly Members Bill [HL]
My Lords, first, we wish to be associated with the comments made by the noble Baroness on the PSNI and the security situation, which, as we all know, is far from ideal at the moment. We in the Conservative Party support this Bill so far as it goes. The noble Baroness the Leader of the House has explained in her introduction that the Assembly is currently prevented from establishing an independent body to set its salaries and allowances, even if it wants to. This Bill will give the Assembly that power, which is available, as already stated by the Minister, to the devolved legislatures in Scotland and Wales. Given recent events in Westminster, it is easy to see why such a move is appropriate. The power to set up an independent body is clearly keenly wanted by the Assembly. The Government have been good enough to share with me and other noble Lords certain correspondence between the Speaker of the Assembly and the Minister of State, which has gone on because of other things that have been happening. That help and correspondence has continued throughout this afternoon and I was able to clarify one or two things with the Minister of State, Paul Goggins. The Speaker confirms that there is, ""support across the parties represented in the Assembly for the establishment of an Independent Statutory Body"," which would be able to give effect to the recommendation in Section 4 of the recent Assembly Commission's report. That report was due to be debated yesterday in the Assembly, but was withdrawn at short notice and thus was the cause of the necessary correspondence this afternoon. I was informed by officials that the Assembly had decided to return to certain areas for reconsideration. As a result, we have not yet been able to see a copy. However, other noble Lords will be aware that details, which are unconfirmed, about the levels of remuneration for MLAs were leaked and excited a good deal of interest in the media in Northern Ireland. I read those details on the way in to your Lordships’ House yesterday. The very fact that we have had this small hiccup is a good indication of how controversial the matter of politicians’ pay and expenses is with the public. We have already seen that at Westminster. The parties in Northern Ireland are not immune to public opinion either. Our colleagues in the Ulster Unionist Party have been leading calls for an independent body to determine the salaries paid to MLAs. They and we endorse the principle of this Bill, although it would have been useful to have read the commission’s report before being asked by the noble Baroness to support the Bill today. We will support it and thank the Government for helping us understand what is and what is not in it. The noble Baroness has explained that the Bill does not require an independent body to be set up, it merely allows the option of doing so. But a copy of one of the letters sent by the Speaker of the Assembly to the Minister of State, Paul Goggins, states quite clearly that he Assembly will bring forward a Bill to establish "an independent statutory body". Given the widespread support for the move and the obvious eagerness of the parties in the Assembly for a body as expressed in the Speaker’s letter to the Minister of State, can the noble Baroness tell us why the Bill does not go further and set up the body itself? Can she also outline what plans have been discussed by the Government to help facilitate the establishment of an independent body once the Bill is on the statute book? If there are details in the pipeline, it is important for noble Lords to hear them. What plans are there for the appointment system to the independent body? How will its independence and accountability be guaranteed? How will it be paid, and within what sort of brackets? How will the chairman be selected? There are many thoughts of that kind which I suspect would have been debated in the Assembly or in the commission yesterday, but were not. I said at the outset that we on these Benches support the Bill as far as it goes, but it does not go as far as it might. This would have been a timely opportunity also to look at the matter of "double jobbing". That is how the problem is referred to in Northern Ireland and so it is the term that I will use, although the mischief really being described is that of double mandates. Some 16 of the 18 MPs that Northern Ireland sends to this Parliament are also MLAs in Stormont. My party and the Ulster Unionists are on record as opposing this state of affairs. At the very basic, practical level, the distance between London and Belfast makes it hard for us to see how Members who have been elected both to Westminster and to Stormont can give adequate time to the representation of their constituents in either. On Monday 23 November in Stormont, the Ulster Unionists moved a Motion calling, ""on all political parties within the Assembly to commit to an end to ‘double jobbing’ by the next Assembly election in 2011, to protect the integrity of the Northern Ireland Assembly"," a Motion that was substantially altered by an amendment moved by the Democratic Unionist Party and which it won by a vote of 34 to 23, that sought to extend the deadline until 2015. The Kelly report, which we are committed to implementing, raises the question of double jobbing. It seems that the devolved national legislatures do not have the power to prohibit any of their Members also being Members of the Westminster Parliament. The power to implement the report’s recommendations therefore lies with Westminster. The committee’s view, which we share, is that double jobbing should be brought to an end as soon as possible. Why was no thought given to that by the Government when they had the Bill on their desk? The Long Title of the Bill is narrowly drawn but we will examine the possibilities of laying an amendment in Grand Committee which covers this issue. We await the publication of the commission’s report. We will scrutinise the Bill in its further stages with a rigour that your Lordships’ House would expect and we will continue to support the Government.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 715 c722-4
- Session
- 2009-10
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords chamber
- Subjects
- Devolved matters Allowances Devolution Dual mandate Northern Ireland Pay Public appointments Workplace pensions Northern Ireland Assembly Members Northern Ireland government Speaker
- Legislation
- Northern Ireland Assembly Members Bill (HL) 2009-10
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2023-12-11 10:04:47 +0000
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_598417
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_598417
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_598417