Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Bew (Crossbench) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 1 December 2009. It occurred during Debate on bill on Northern Ireland Assembly Members Bill [HL].


Northern Ireland Assembly Members Bill [HL]

My Lords, I support the Bill on its merits and because we are at a moment of crisis in Northern Ireland, as several noble Lords have already acknowledged. It is entirely right that this House should support an initiative which has the common support of all the parties in the Northern Ireland Assembly. It is an issue upon which they are agreed at a moment when some of the parties appear to be talking themselves over a cliff and initiating, possibly, a major political crisis in the institutions of Northern Ireland over the next few weeks, a crisis which I devoutly hope will be averted. So I think it is entirely right that we respond sympathetically to what is, in effect, a request from the Northern Ireland Assembly, and I was very glad to hear the words of the Speaker in that Assembly this afternoon. However, we have to bear certain considerations in mind. In her opening remarks, the noble Baroness the Leader of the House referred to a discussion that took place in recent days in Northern Ireland about Assembly Members and salary issues, and about the widespread unease that was expressed when it was reported that Assembly Members were seeking a salary increase of 17 per cent. As the noble Lords, Lord Smith and Lord Glentoran, said, there has been widespread unease about the delay in ending the double-jobbing system and the fact that it has been put off until 2015. These issues cause a great deal of tension, and therefore it is wise that the Assembly is taking action to move them into a more neutral sphere and create an impartial body which, it is hoped, will be able to deal with some of these questions. However, in many respects, the most important and sensitive argument relating to the Northern Ireland Assembly concerns not so much the question of salaries, which after all are significantly below those of Members of the Scottish Parliament, but the size of the Assembly, which, in turn, is also a very sensitive point. An Assembly of 108 Members seems very large for a population as small as that of Northern Ireland. To have 108 Members seems generous, to put it mildly. On the other hand, there are serious political reasons why that number was reached. Two things come to my mind, and I have a question for the noble Baroness. I believe, although I should like clarification, that the new independent body will deal just with salaries and conditions and not with the size of the Assembly. Whether it does so or not, the point is that all these issues in Northern Ireland, some of which seem quaint or unusual, are the product of a rather complicated political history. It is absolutely essential that any body formed to deal with this matter understands the pros and cons of the various arguments. I am not stating a view on whether, for example, 108 is the right or wrong number of Members of the Assembly; I am simply saying that there is a complicated political history which explains why that number was reached. Many other decisions connected with the Assembly have a complicated political back story. Therefore, it is vital that any new independent body dealing with this issue understands the back story so that it is able to reach the wisest possible decision.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
715 c725-6 
Session
2009-10
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Devolved matters Allowances Devolution Dual mandate Northern Ireland Pay Public appointments Workplace pensions Northern Ireland Assembly Members Northern Ireland government Speaker
Legislation
Northern Ireland Assembly Members Bill (HL) 2009-10
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk