Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Tope (Liberal Democrat) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 18 March 2010. It occurred during Debates on delegated legislation on Environmental Civil Sanctions (England) Order 2010.


Environmental Civil Sanctions (England) Order 2010

My Lords, I thank the Minister for introducing the statutory instrument and explaining it very fully to us. I, too, welcome the introduction of civil sanctions. As the Minister said in his introduction, they are a useful tool between what can sometimes be the heavy hand of criminal prosecution, with all that goes with that, and the alternative of no prosecution at all. I am reasonably familiar in other aspects of life with the use of civil sanctions. I speak as a member of a local authority that sometimes resorts to such measures, and I know that they act both as a deterrent and, sometimes, as an incentive. From both points of view, that is useful. The powers given here will be valuable in encouraging and, where necessary, ensuring compliance, not by the worst offenders, for whom criminal prosecution is probably the only way, but by those who, in the main, might wish to comply but, perhaps, do not try hard enough or who sometimes do not understand enough and for whom an appropriate civil sanction, which is not necessarily monetary, can act as the right incentive. These statutory instruments were debated in another place on Tuesday and many of the questions and concerns were answered there. The noble Lord, Lord Taylor of Holbeach, asked a number of useful, helpful and pertinent questions, and I look forward to the Minister’s reply. I do not need to repeat what was said in another place or what has already been said here. I have one remaining concern. It was addressed in another place, but not completely. It relates to the power of entry granted under these regulations. I understand the necessity, but Parliament needs to be very cautious when extending powers of entry still further. I shall not rehearse the hundreds, I think now thousands, of instances where power of entry is granted, but it is an area of proper concern over which we need to be cautious. We need to understand exactly what we are granting. In another place, the Minister said that the powers under these orders are similar to those already enjoyed by the Environment Agency. Does "similar to" mean "the same as" or "not quite the same as"? If it means "not quite the same as", what is the difference between the powers granted here and the powers that the Environment Agency already has? I know that this does not apply to domestic premises and we hope that in all cases those whose premises are being entered will always co-operate and comply, but it is inevitable that, sometimes, that will not happen. What happens when right of entry is refused and confrontation perhaps ensues? What power is available? Does it require police action or court action, and what sanction is there should that happen? Those are my main outstanding concerns, given the debate that has taken place in another place and in this place. I look forward to the Minister’s answers and give a general welcome to these regulations.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
718 c306-7GC 
Session
2009-10
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Devolved matters Business Enforcement Fixed penalties Environment protection Fines National Assembly for Wales Pollution control Wales
Legislation
Environmental Civil Sanctions (England) Order 2010
Environmental Civil Sanctions (Miscellaneous Amendments) (England) Regulations 2010
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk