Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Dubs (Labour) in the House of Lords on Monday, 22 March 2010. It occurred during Debate on select committee report on House Committee: Third Report.


House Committee: Third Report

My Lords, I bumped into man; we got into a discussion; and he said what many noble Lords have said: "You’re all on the make". There was nothing that I could say that would persuade him otherwise. I agree with what my noble friends and the noble Baroness, Lady Williams, have said: people in this country are angry, and no amount of persuasion on our part will calm them down unless we change the system dramatically. One has to talk to people; the hatred for politicians has to be felt. No amount of rational argument will make people calm down. We have got to change the system, and I hope that this is the first and important step on the way to doing so. I therefore welcome the report. I add two points. First, it is absolutely essential, as my noble friend Lord Soley said, that these issues stem from an independent body that will determine and oversee what we are about—I think that that is clear and widely accepted. Only in that way can we demonstrate to the public that it is not us doing it for ourselves, but that independent people are adjudicating on the merits of our entitlements. My second point has not been mentioned so much, although the Chairman of Committees did so in passing. Although I welcome paragraph 8, there may be some grey areas, and individual circumstances alter. It is important for there to be somewhere we can go, independent of the House, to ask for adjudication, and where we can say, "I have a dilemma; I want to play it absolutely straight. Will you please give me clear advice, guidance and virtual instruction as to what I can claim and what I can’t and how I can do that?" That is probably lacking in what we have so far, and I should like it to be built into the system. Then, we would not need to agonise and talk to colleagues in the Bishops’ Bar, saying, "Look, I’m not sure what to do about this". It should be clear where we should go, and we should get that advice. Everybody else in the country can go to their employer and ask for adjudication on any of their claims. We are not able to do that so far. I hope that the new system will embody it when we get the full report from the noble Lord, Lord Wakeham. In the mean time, I welcome the report and I hope that we get on with it.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
718 c780 
Session
2009-10
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Disclosure of information Audit Allowances Housing House of Lords Location Peers National Audit Office
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk