Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Baroness Royall of Blaisdon (Labour) in the House of Lords on Monday, 22 March 2010. It occurred during Debate on select committee report on House Committee: Third Report.


House Committee: Third Report

My Lords, we have had a serious and considered debate today, and I am grateful to all Members of this House who have taken part. I know that these are important issues for the Members of the House, important to the House itself and important beyond the House to Parliament, politics and the public. We are addressing today what the House Committee’s report, referred to in the Motion before us, calls a "main weakness" in the current scheme of financial support for Members of your Lordships' House—that is, the definition, designation and declaration of the main residence of Members of this House claiming overnight allowances. Not only do we not have a definition that is clear and precise, at present we have no definition at all, as the noble Lord, Lord McNally, pointed out. He was also right to say that we cannot and must not act retrospectively. That is in part an answer to the noble Lord, Lord Maclennan of Rogart, who was right to say that process is important. We must understand the process and have confidence in it. If the House adopts the proposal today and the House Committee agrees on the forms to be sent out, when Members see the forms they will have more confidence in the process. Today we are replacing a lack of clarity with clarity, ambiguousness with unambiguousness and no definition not just with a definition but with a good, robust definition, despite what my noble friend says. I was going to answer my noble friend Lord Gilbert, who I think is my fellow slave to party, but he was dealt with very well by my noble friend Lady Symons—a very sensible woman, if I may say so, who was endorsed by the equally sensible noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss. The discussion of these matters in today’s debate has been a helpful consideration of the issues, but I am glad that at the beginning the noble Lord, Lord Strathclyde, spoke of the cross-party agreement that exists about them, not just between our parties but with the noble Lord, Lord McNally, and the noble Baroness, Lady D’Souza. We often speak of differences between this our House and the other place, differences that we celebrate. The cross-party working and agreement that we have on these issues is a matter for celebration. The publication of our expenses on a quarterly basis, in answer to the noble Lord, Lord Strathclyde, is a good first step on the road to a rolling publication, but that is a matter for another day which must be discussed at some future meeting of the House Committee. I say "future", though, because we have to get the next step going—that is, quarterly publication—before we should start talking about a rolling programme. The noble Baroness, Lady D’Souza, reminded us of the need for personal responsibility and the fact that rules are not enough. She is right. I am also grateful to her for drawing our attention to the importance of regular audit checks, both internally and by the National Audit Office. That is an important innovation. The noble Baroness, Lady Williams of Crosby, and other noble Lords made important points about our relationship with the public, and she spoke specifically about the culture of entitlement. I too am concerned about such a culture, and that is why I believe the reports of the SSRB and the Wakeham group are so important to improve our system, to increase our responsibility and to restore trust. My noble friend Lord Soley is right when he says that the system that we have is our responsibility; we cannot blame the press for everything, and it is our responsibility to put this right. The noble Baroness, Lady Williams, spoke of her fears about the mood of our fellow citizens. The fears and concerns that she expresses are chilling but realistic—democracy and our democratic system have undoubtedly been damaged by what has happened in Parliament over the past couple of years. Today’s decision will be just a step on the road towards restoring public confidence. I agree with my noble friend Lord Puttnam that we have to align ourselves with public opinion and align our expectations with theirs. The noble Baroness raised the quasi-definition of visiting your main residence only once a month. I accept the fact that this was the responsibility of the House Committee—we accept political responsibility for that—but in some ways we were misrepresented by the press. Once a month was always in the context of residing or staying, rather than, say, a visit to your greenhouse for a day, and it was coupled with saying that we should be there for Recesses too. I want to put that clearly on the record. In many ways, my noble friend Lady Symons also responded to the point made by the noble Lord, Lord McNally, about the SSRB’s concern about the definition of "reasonable commuting distance". I believe that we have to be absolutely clear in our definitions to ensure that we can exert our own responsibility for our own security, but also to ensure that the public can have a clear understanding about what we should and should not do. That is why the definition we have before us today is the right one. I draw your Lordships’ attention to the fifth principle mentioned by the SSRB in its report, which is, ""to minimise the scope for abuse of allowances and for manipulation, by drawing up unambiguous rules for expenses claims"." I believe that the definitions which we have today are unambiguous. My noble friends Lord Soley, Lord McIntosh and Lord Dubs alerted us to the problems of self-regulation. That is a subject for another day, as I mentioned in my earlier speech, but it is the Government’s policy for this House to move from self-regulation to independent regulation. That is their ambition and, as I say, we will discuss that on other occasions. My noble friend Lord Soley also mentioned the new publication arrangements, which he feared would open the door to FOI queries. I look forward to receiving a letter from my noble friend, of course, but an inevitable part of these proposals—one which I welcome—is to put more information into the public domain. It is better and more open to do that proactively rather than await an FOI request. In many ways we are therefore being proactive rather than reactive, which is a good thing. The noble Lord, Lord Sutherland, asked about CGT and I am grateful for the intervention from the noble Baroness, Lady O’Cathain. We will await the advice from the ad hoc group on that matter, because it has clearly not been addressed by the House Committee to date. In conclusion, I echo and strongly support the wise words of the noble Lord the Chairman of Committees in opening today’s debate. He said that with the introduction of proper definitions, better enforcement and a greater degree of transparency that he hoped—as I, too, hope—that as a House we could, now and in the coming months, move on from what has been a difficult period for the House. We know that there is more work for the House to do, and I am grateful for all the work undertaken by the noble Lord, Lord Wakeham, and his colleagues. We have the new code of conduct and the new guidance to the code and, with the two changes that we are considering today, we have made significant moves forward. However, today’s proposals, important as they are, form only a part of the work which this House charged the ad hoc group under the noble Lord, Lord Wakeham, to carry out following the report from the SSRB. We welcomed that report and its recommendations, but we should heed the wise words of the noble Lord, Lord MacGregor, and of others. Those were recommendations; we will follow them in so far as we believe that it is right to do so; but they were not a tablet of stone. We would certainly like to have concluded the work on the SSRB and the ad hoc group by now, but it has not been possible to do so. There is still work to be done on these issues. The crucial thing is to get it right. We need a system that is fair, transparent and reasonable. We need a report that commands maximum support inside this House, but also maximum support outside it. In advance of that, I believe that we are today taking a very good and clear step forward, one which offers real benefits to all involved and one which I commend to the House. The noble Lord, Lord Williamson, reminded us of the need for a strict, robust definition; I think that is what the noble Lord, Lord Jay, also endorsed. I believe that is what we have before us today, and I urge the House to support the Motion from the House Committee. Motion agreed.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
718 c782-4 
Session
2009-10
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Disclosure of information Audit Allowances Housing House of Lords Location Peers National Audit Office
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk