---

Common Consolidated Corporate Tax Base

Indeed; thank you so much for that sedentary intervention. It is very interesting that, as my right hon. Friend the Member for Wokingham (Mr Redwood) was saying, between 1688 and 1972, taxation could not be levied without the permission of the House. Since 1972, tax rates have been changed at the whim of the European Union. What is more, it happens to use duties levied on imports in exactly the way that James II would have been familiar with—it takes the same anti-parliamentary approach. James II called them tonnage and poundage; the European Union calls them anti-dumping measures but it changes them with arrogance as it sees fit. I want to talk about the legal aspects of this issue, because they are the absolute crux of it. I raise this point with my hon. Friend the Minister because there is no point in negotiating for months if there is no legal basis in the first place. The Government should be very clear and rigorous about this and should take it, if necessary, all the way through to the European Court of Justice. That might be a Court in which many of us do not have a great deal of confidence and it might be a Court that is in principle a federalist Court, but none the less it is there and its procedures should be used. Let me read out paragraph 2.12 of the European Scrutiny Committee's conclusion on this issue:"““The draft Directive is concerned with direct taxation. The legal base cited for it is Article 115 TFEU. This article allows EU legislation to approximate national legislation which directly affects the operation of the single market, but””—" this is the key point—"““this provision is expressly 'without prejudice to Article 114'. Article 114(2) TFEU provides that Article 114(1) TFEU 'shall not apply to fiscal provisions'. Article 113 TFEU, the only provision referring to the harmonisation of taxation, is limited in its scope to 'turnover taxes, excise duties and other forms of indirect taxation'. There is therefore no express provision in the Treaty for the harmonisation of direct taxation.””"