Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Crickhowell (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Monday, 26 March 2012. It occurred during Debate on select committee report on Procedure of the House.


Procedure of the House

That is rather an interesting exchange. It has magnified what I had intended to say. However, it was also a little unusual. This is a House matter, and normally we leave the introduction of such measures for individual Members of this House. It is a little unusual—I am not saying it is unique—to have a letter of that kind. It is also slightly unusual to receive an urgent message to get in touch with the Leader's Office. I was on the train up from Wales, and I was asked to go and meet him. As usual we had the most civilised and delicate discussion about these matters, in which we agreed to differ. I explained that I would be opposing this Motion because I think that the timing is catastrophically unfortunate. I do not think that it should be introduced as an experiment when we are going to have this major Bill before us, with the suspicion that will inevitably arise—and has arisen—that the decks are being cleared. I also support almost everything else that my noble friend Lord Cormack said. He referred to the possibility of the kind of disciplines being introduced into this House that have been introduced in the Commons. Indeed, the letter from my noble friend the Leader says that this measure is being introduced in order to avoid, "““having to introduce Commons-style restrictions on members' ability to table amendments””." Is it a threat? I hope not. I am totally opposed to doing this at this time. I am glad that the proposals that we should sit in the morning, which I spoke against long ago, have been withdrawn. I do not think that this set of proposals is any more acceptable. The wisest thing now would be for my noble friend the Leader, and those responsible, to listen to what has been said and to take the proposals away and reconsider them. If he will not agree to do that and my noble friend Lord Cormack presses his amendment to the Motion, I will vote for it, and I hope that it will be widely supported in the House.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
736 c1140-1 
Session
2010-12
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
House of Lords Parliamentary procedure Government bills Ministerial statements Times of sittings Written questions House of Lords Grand Committee
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk