Skip to main content

Written question asked by Baroness Deech (Crossbench) on Thursday, 14 May 2026, in the House of Lords. It was due for an answer on Friday, 29 May 2026. It was answered by Baroness Levitt (Labour) on Thursday, 28 May 2026 on behalf of the Ministry of Justice.


Tribunals: Conflict of Interests

Question

To ask His Majesty's Government what is the governance framework that governs conflicts of interest in the tribunal system.

Answer

The conduct of judges is a matter for the independent judiciary. It would therefore not be proper for the Government to require the publication of declarations of interest in relation to any court or type of judge. Doing so would risk undermining judicial independence.

All judges have taken an oath to act impartially. The Guide to Judicial Conduct sets out what this means in practice, stating that “judicial office holders should, so far as is reasonable, avoid extra-judicial activities that are likely to cause them to have to refrain from sitting because of a reasonable apprehension of bias or because of a conflict of interest that would arise from the activity”. The Guide then explains how parties to a case might approach applications to the court for the recusal of a judge because of a real or perceived conflict of interest.

Accordingly, the remit of the Judicial Conduct Investigations Office does not extend to complaints of bias in judicial decision-making. It can, however, investigate types of conduct such as the publication of “content which could damage public confidence in judicial impartiality”.

This means that although there is no register of judges’ interests, there are mechanisms in the court system and through the Judicial Conduct Investigations Office where issues about potential conflicts of interest can be raised.


Secondary information

Type
Written question
Reference
HL95
Session
2026-27
Related items
Tribunals: Conflict of Interests
Monday, 15 June 2026
Written questions
House of Lords
Grouped for answer
Yes
Subjects
Conflict of interests Tribunals
Link
View this Written question on www.parliament.uk