Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord True (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Wednesday, 4 September 2019. It occurred during Debate on bill on Business of the House.


Business of the House

It might help the House if I responded for 30 seconds to the amendment to withdraw the amendment, because I think that the spirit of the House is right on this. I shall not press the amendment because I do not want this great House to record a second vote in favour of a guillotine. That would be very sad, particularly against my Motion, which asked for the guillotine not to be applied in a case where a Bill has been guillotined in the other House.

In the heat of these debates—I acknowledge that I perhaps believe a bit too much in the sense of liberty of this House—it would be a great pity if we put on the record of the House that we had rejected Motions that I proposed and, by implication, supported guillotining a Measure in both Houses. I therefore intend to ask the leave of the House to withdraw the amendment, but I hope that there might be a little pause, as some have asked, and some consideration, because the reality is that there has to be a total deal, it involves the other place, the leader of the Opposition and the Prime Minister, and we cannot deliver that in this Chamber. In some way or another, because someone has to give something up—in a good deal, people on both sides give something up—this side of the House has to keep an insurance policy against the imposition of the guillotine if there is no deal.

6.45 pm

I therefore suggest that a pause, rather than going on to later amendments, might be helpful, but the mood of the House will decide absolutely. I do not want to proceed until 10.01 on Friday morning, but my goodness, I am prepared to do so to prevent the imposition of the guillotine. I hope that the end desired by all can be achieved by means other than a war of attrition.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
799 c1055 
Session
2017-19
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Civil proceedings House of Lords Parliamentary procedure Parliamentary scrutiny Timetabling of bills Order of business Constitution Committee Committee of the Whole House (HL) Prorogation Brexit
Legislation
European Union (Withdrawal) (No. 6) Bill 2017-19
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on hansard.parliament.uk