Mr. Matthew Taylor: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence what assessment the Chemical Defence Establishment at Porton Down has
made of the toxicity to humans of (a) the nerve agent GF and (b) sarin GB. [127132]
Dr. Moonie: This is a matter for the Chief Executive of the Defence Evaluation and Research Agency. I have asked the Chief Executive
to write to the hon. Member.
Letter from John Chisholm to Mr. Matthew Taylor, dated 27 June 2000:
I am replying to your parliamentary question about nerve agents and their toxicity to humans since the laboratories at Porton Down
are part of the Defence Evaluation and Research Agency (DERA).
GB (sarin) and GF (cyclosarin) are organophosphorus nerve agents developed during World War II in Germany. Both agents are highly
toxic chemicals. GB is a highly volatile liquid and is a particular hazard following inhalation, GF is some 30-35 times less
volatile and presents a particular hazard from absorption through skin. In hot climates, however, GF may also present a significant
hazard from inhalation.
Both GB and GF are potent inhibitors of the enzyme acetylcholinesterase, which is responsible for the control of the important
chemical messenger acetylcholine within the nervous system. When humans are poisoned, the signs and symptoms of acute poisoning
progress from a general feeling of malaise, pinpoint pupils (miosis), excessive sweating, salivation, runny nose and breathing
difficulties, through nausea, vomiting and muscle tremor, to loss of consciousness, convulsions and death from respiratory failure.
The severity of these signs and their rate of progress depends upon the dose and route of exposure to the nerve agents. In general,
those agents absorbed through the skin, such as GF, will exhibit a delayed onset of poisoning and those which are inhaled, such as
GB, will exhibit a very rapid onset (within 1-2 min) of signs and symptoms of poisoning.
A knowledge of the toxicity of these nerve agents has been built up over the years since the Second World War. Assessments have been
prompted by intelligence reports of the chemical arsenals of potential aggressors, for example Iraq. They have been based upon
studies in animals and to a limited extent in humans conducted within the UK and the Allied Nations. A number of these studies were
carried out at Porton Down between 1948 and 1989. The last trial looked at the effects on the eye of low levels of GB. The trial was
conducted to assess the effects from "the maximum dosage of nerve agent vapour to the eyes acceptable for aircrew" under NATO
prescribed conditions. Scientists at Porton Down have also undertaken three paper exercises to examine the possible long-term
effects of nerve agent exposure using the service medical records of volunteers previously exposed to GB. None of the three studies
showed any significant difference between the patterns of days lost through illness, the number of specialist appointments or the
number of hospital admissions between the control and exposed groups.
Medical countermeasures to both GB and GF have been developed at CBD Porton Down and the combination of pre-treatment with Nerve
Agent Pre-Treatment Set (NAPS) tablets and use of the ComboPen injector, which contains atropine, an oxime (P2S) and an
anticonvulsant (Avizafone), provide effective antidotes against poisoning by these agents.
I hope the above is helpful.