My Lords—

My Lords—

My Lords—

My Lords—

My Lords, I will give way. I am sure that the noble Baroness will do the same for me in a moment.

My Lords, I will give way. I am sure that the noble Baroness will do the same for me in a moment.

My Lords, I acknowledge that those who have been campaigning for the Bill, inside and outside here, are well motivated. Many have watched a loved one die in great discomfort, even agony, and are informed by grief. Understandably, they do not want that for their loved ones or themselves. I...

My Lords, I acknowledge that those who have been campaigning for the Bill, inside and outside here, are well motivated. Many have watched a loved one die in great discomfort, even agony, and are informed by grief. Understandably, they do not want that for their loved ones or themselves. I...

Such moral dilemmas hint at the fundamental shift in the raison d’être of medicine that is required. A systemic shift will be needed to change the NHS constitution and redefine “medical treatment”. So I am grateful to this House, whether or not it has taken 14 days, that we heard...

Such moral dilemmas hint at the fundamental shift in the raison d’être of medicine that is required. A systemic shift will be needed to change the NHS constitution and redefine “medical treatment”. So I am grateful to this House, whether or not it has taken 14 days, that we heard...

The confusion is that a doctor’s duty is to present a patient with all the possible treatments they could have. If they refuse to mention chemotherapy or that the patient could take this painkiller, they would be negligent and could get struck off. If assisted dying becomes a medical treatment,...

The confusion is that a doctor’s duty is to present a patient with all the possible treatments they could have. If they refuse to mention chemotherapy or that the patient could take this painkiller, they would be negligent and could get struck off. If assisted dying becomes a medical treatment,...

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Cass—that was totally compelling. We will all have to read it and reread it, but it gave us a real sense of what it would be like. Sometimes, we are talking in the abstract.

In a more concrete sense, I think of this...

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Cass—that was totally compelling. We will all have to read it and reread it, but it gave us a real sense of what it would be like. Sometimes, we are talking in the abstract.

In a more concrete sense, I think of this...

“For goodness’ sake”—well, a bit of empathy might be helpful.

Our main focus is understandably on doctors, even nurses, but we must be careful not to assume that those with medical degrees—the professionals—are entitled to a greater respect for their consciences than other relevant workers: like porters.

I have previously spoken about...

“For goodness’ sake”—well, a bit of empathy might be helpful.

Our main focus is understandably on doctors, even nurses, but we must be careful not to assume that those with medical degrees—the professionals—are entitled to a greater respect for their consciences than other relevant workers: like porters.

I have previously spoken about...

Irony noted. Anyway, it is—

Irony noted. Anyway, it is—

Royal colleges and trade unions want better guarantees. When we discussed the Employment Rights Bill—

Royal colleges and trade unions want better guarantees. When we discussed the Employment Rights Bill—

I sat for many hours through the debates on the Employment Rights Bill. When I said that there was a plethora of rights and that we were overdoing it, I was treated with some contempt.

I have to finish. The fear is that once assisted dying is normalised as a medical...

I sat for many hours through the debates on the Employment Rights Bill. When I said that there was a plethora of rights and that we were overdoing it, I was treated with some contempt.

I have to finish. The fear is that once assisted dying is normalised as a medical...

This is meant to be a debate. I have taken a lot of opposition points. Let me finish. The worry is that civil liability protections do not cover where a duty is owed to the patients. How can doctors who do not wish to offer or discuss assisted dying be...

This is meant to be a debate. I have taken a lot of opposition points. Let me finish. The worry is that civil liability protections do not cover where a duty is owed to the patients. How can doctors who do not wish to offer or discuss assisted dying be...

My Lords, I cannot let the noble Lord, Lord Pannick, get away with that. What happened on Wednesday night was a separate issue. As it happens, I argued for a change in the law in relation to decriminalising abortion—but now I am on this side. This sort of easy “swatting...

My Lords, I cannot let the noble Lord, Lord Pannick, get away with that. What happened on Wednesday night was a separate issue. As it happens, I argued for a change in the law in relation to decriminalising abortion—but now I am on this side. This sort of easy “swatting...

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Llanfaes; that was a tour de force. Goodness knows, we rarely agree,

and I am hardly a Plaid supporter, but I am from Wales. I want to reflect on couple of tiny things that she said in why I wanted...

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Llanfaes; that was a tour de force. Goodness knows, we rarely agree,

and I am hardly a Plaid supporter, but I am from Wales. I want to reflect on couple of tiny things that she said in why I wanted...

My Lords, it is hard to follow the noble Lords, Lord Moylan and Lord Carlile, whose contributions were made with such panache, wit and insight. What really intimidated me was the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, saying, “This amendment is all about understanding the mathematics”. I thought, “Oh God, I’ve put...

My Lords, it is hard to follow the noble Lords, Lord Moylan and Lord Carlile, whose contributions were made with such panache, wit and insight. What really intimidated me was the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, saying, “This amendment is all about understanding the mathematics”. I thought, “Oh God, I’ve put...

I just want to ask the noble Baroness for one clarification. I agree that most doctors are not brutal and do not say, “You’ve got six months and that’s it”. I asked whether the Bill, which requires you to have a six-month prognosis to access the service, will encourage doctors...

I just want to ask the noble Baroness for one clarification. I agree that most doctors are not brutal and do not say, “You’ve got six months and that’s it”. I asked whether the Bill, which requires you to have a six-month prognosis to access the service, will encourage doctors...

My Lords, I wanted to sound really definitive in saying that I oppose Amendment 424 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Monckton, which would remove Clause 208, and that I oppose Amendments 425 and 426D. However, the good thing about this place is that I listened to the...

My Lords, I wanted to sound really definitive in saying that I oppose Amendment 424 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Monckton, which would remove Clause 208, and that I oppose Amendments 425 and 426D. However, the good thing about this place is that I listened to the...

I have finished. That was it.

I have finished. That was it.

My Lords, what influenced me to look positively at a number of amendments in this group, and to table Amendment 150, was that some jurisdictions with assisted dying legislation explicitly prohibit doctors from initiating assisted dying discussions. I know that there was a bit of a row earlier about Australia,...

My Lords, what influenced me to look positively at a number of amendments in this group, and to table Amendment 150, was that some jurisdictions with assisted dying legislation explicitly prohibit doctors from initiating assisted dying discussions. I know that there was a bit of a row earlier about Australia,...

That is very helpful. When I see a uniform, I get a bit quivery as well—

That is very helpful. When I see a uniform, I get a bit quivery as well—