My Lords, I thank noble Lords for raising so many aspects of the scope of the Bill. I recognise the sentiment among noble Lords today about the importance of expanding its scope. Our approach has been to target regulatory requirements on a select number of essential services, while using non-regulatory...

My Lords, I thank noble Lords for raising so many aspects of the scope of the Bill. I recognise the sentiment among noble Lords today about the importance of expanding its scope. Our approach has been to target regulatory requirements on a select number of essential services, while using non-regulatory...

I am sorry to interrupt the Minister, but clarification along the way would be very helpful. She has asked her officials to see what other sectors should be brought in and has given an indication of the kind of test, but we are dealing with a bit more fog here....

I am sorry to interrupt the Minister, but clarification along the way would be very helpful. She has asked her officials to see what other sectors should be brought in and has given an indication of the kind of test, but we are dealing with a bit more fog here....

I was referring to the process by which sectors can be brought into scope of the Bill, as set out in it and using the powers in the Bill. That would follow the process I just mentioned, which would be subject to consultation and the affirmative procedure. That is the...

I was referring to the process by which sectors can be brought into scope of the Bill, as set out in it and using the powers in the Bill. That would follow the process I just mentioned, which would be subject to consultation and the affirmative procedure. That is the...

But the powers are further down the track; they are under secondary legislation. I am assuming the Minister is promising that the Secretary of State will set out the criteria by which a new sector is brought in. Is that right? Do we have any indication, apart from what the...

But the powers are further down the track; they are under secondary legislation. I am assuming the Minister is promising that the Secretary of State will set out the criteria by which a new sector is brought in. Is that right? Do we have any indication, apart from what the...

I have highlighted a few of those criteria regarding the extent to which the activity is essential to the economy or the day-to-day functioning of society in all or part of the UK. Obviously, we already have the list of critical national infrastructure. We need to go through a whole...

I have highlighted a few of those criteria regarding the extent to which the activity is essential to the economy or the day-to-day functioning of society in all or part of the UK. Obviously, we already have the list of critical national infrastructure. We need to go through a whole...

My Lords, if the Minister could commit to adding that to the conversations we are bound to have to have between now and Report—

My Lords, if the Minister could commit to adding that to the conversations we are bound to have to have between now and Report—

I am not only committing; I am offering, so I am happy to have the noble Lord confirm that that would be good. I am absolutely offering that as part of the engagement ahead of Report.

I have heard the numerous areas that have been raised for inclusion in the Bill....

I am not only committing; I am offering, so I am happy to have the noble Lord confirm that that would be good. I am absolutely offering that as part of the engagement ahead of Report.

I have heard the numerous areas that have been raised for inclusion in the Bill....

Can I ask the Minister to comment on another point that the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, raised? Why should this not apply to the higher reaches of government? I ask the Minister specifically: what is her view of 607,000 records being stolen, just weeks ago, from the Department for Education?

Can I ask the Minister to comment on another point that the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, raised? Why should this not apply to the higher reaches of government? I ask the Minister specifically: what is her view of 607,000 records being stolen, just weeks ago, from the Department for Education?

I absolutely intend to talk about the public sector. Given the numerous sectors that have been raised, I also want to respond individually on each sector. I absolutely agree that all sectors need to improve their cyber resilience; it is not the case for only those in the regulatory perimeter....

I absolutely intend to talk about the public sector. Given the numerous sectors that have been raised, I also want to respond individually on each sector. I absolutely agree that all sectors need to improve their cyber resilience; it is not the case for only those in the regulatory perimeter....

My Lords, at the risk of irritating the Minister even further, it is great to hear of some of this activity, but that is not the same as bringing it under the terms of the Bill.

My Lords, at the risk of irritating the Minister even further, it is great to hear of some of this activity, but that is not the same as bringing it under the terms of the Bill.

It is not the same. I wish to stress that the importance of strengthening cyber resilience can happen outside of legislation being put in place. There are many efforts that can go on to improve cyber resilience.

Moving on to the amendment of the noble Baroness, Lady Ludford, and her question...

It is not the same. I wish to stress that the importance of strengthening cyber resilience can happen outside of legislation being put in place. There are many efforts that can go on to improve cyber resilience.

Moving on to the amendment of the noble Baroness, Lady Ludford, and her question...

I thank the Minister for her point about the Government Cyber Action Plan, but do the strength of her arguments there not completely reinforce the urgent need to have the national cyber action plan, so that we can assess overall the cyber strategy of the nation and the role of...

I thank the Minister for her point about the Government Cyber Action Plan, but do the strength of her arguments there not completely reinforce the urgent need to have the national cyber action plan, so that we can assess overall the cyber strategy of the nation and the role of...

The cyber action plan is a very thorough document. It sets out a plan over many years to improve the cyber resilience of the Government and the public sector, which I think we all agree is absolutely needed. The fact that incidents

are still occurring in the public sector reinforces...

The cyber action plan is a very thorough document. It sets out a plan over many years to improve the cyber resilience of the Government and the public sector, which I think we all agree is absolutely needed. The fact that incidents

are still occurring in the public sector reinforces...

The Minister pointed to three examples of where education is considering issues around cyber security, specifically in schools and only 80% of colleges. One of the concerns I outlined in my contribution was around the examining bodies for both our secondary schools and universities. There was no mention of universities....

The Minister pointed to three examples of where education is considering issues around cyber security, specifically in schools and only 80% of colleges. One of the concerns I outlined in my contribution was around the examining bodies for both our secondary schools and universities. There was no mention of universities....

The general approach is that the lead government department has responsibility for ensuring cyber security in the areas that it covers.

I will need to write to my noble friend specifically on exam boards and examining authorities. I know that the DfE supports bodies that support higher education and further...

The general approach is that the lead government department has responsibility for ensuring cyber security in the areas that it covers.

I will need to write to my noble friend specifically on exam boards and examining authorities. I know that the DfE supports bodies that support higher education and further...

Can I ask a couple of questions and make one comment? The more we hear about the conversation that is taking place on the Bill, the more anomalous the factors that have been chosen or included in the scheme become. Let me give the example of space. Plenty of us...

Can I ask a couple of questions and make one comment? The more we hear about the conversation that is taking place on the Bill, the more anomalous the factors that have been chosen or included in the scheme become. Let me give the example of space. Plenty of us...

Let me work backwards here. The noble Baroness makes a very good point: the services delivered at local level often mirror those at central government level. At the moment, we are consulting on the question of the best value duty to give additional prominence. One of the issues with mapping...

Let me work backwards here. The noble Baroness makes a very good point: the services delivered at local level often mirror those at central government level. At the moment, we are consulting on the question of the best value duty to give additional prominence. One of the issues with mapping...

My Lords, will the Minister show some greater enthusiasm for her own regulatory scheme? I hope that the criteria that she adopts within the department as to whether certain sectors are going to be brought in will be about not only the criticality of the services but the need for...

My Lords, will the Minister show some greater enthusiasm for her own regulatory scheme? I hope that the criteria that she adopts within the department as to whether certain sectors are going to be brought in will be about not only the criticality of the services but the need for...

I cannot possibly reply on any matters other than political parties. I am left unpersuaded that political parties are sufficiently supported and protected. Maybe bigger parties are not run on a shoestring as much as some of us. I am not talking about national level, but at the local level...

I cannot possibly reply on any matters other than political parties. I am left unpersuaded that political parties are sufficiently supported and protected. Maybe bigger parties are not run on a shoestring as much as some of us. I am not talking about national level, but at the local level...

Moved by

Baroness Kidron

83: After Clause 28, insert the following new Clause—

“Digital Sovereignty Strategy (relevant network and information systems)

(1) The Secretary of State must prepare and maintain a Digital Sovereignty Strategy (“the Strategy”) in relation to relevant network and information systems.

(2) The Strategy must—

(a) set out the Government’s assessment of the...

Moved by

Baroness Kidron

83: After Clause 28, insert the following new Clause—

“Digital Sovereignty Strategy (relevant network and information systems)

(1) The Secretary of State must prepare and maintain a Digital Sovereignty Strategy (“the Strategy”) in relation to relevant network and information systems.

(2) The Strategy must—

(a) set out the Government’s assessment of the...