In what year auditors working for Greater Glasgow Health Board first took note of the exceptional nature of the annual service fees paid to Mr W. J. Duff; and what action was taken.

In what year auditors working for Greater Glasgow Health Board first took note of the exceptional nature of the annual service fees paid to Mr W. J. Duff; and what action was taken.

If he will comment on each investigation since 25th August 1986 into the claims for treatment made by Mr W. J. Duff. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

If he will comment on each investigation since 25th August 1986 into the claims for treatment made by Mr W. J. Duff. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

On how many occasions, and from what date, the Common Services Agency: Dental Practice Division undertook ad-hoc checks on dental payment claim forms submitted by Mr W. J. Duff; what were the conclusions; and what action was taken following each occasion. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

On how many occasions, and from what date, the Common Services Agency: Dental Practice Division undertook ad-hoc checks on dental payment claim forms submitted by Mr W. J. Duff; what were the conclusions; and what action was taken following each occasion. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

If he will request sight of the reports provided by the Director of Practitioner Services to Greater Glasgow Health Board on the circumstances surrounding the case of Mr W. J. Duff; if he will publish the papers requested by Greater Glasgow health board at its meeting on 18 February; and...

If he will request sight of the reports provided by the Director of Practitioner Services to Greater Glasgow Health Board on the circumstances surrounding the case of Mr W. J. Duff; if he will publish the papers requested by Greater Glasgow health board at its meeting on 18 February; and...

What were the dates on which patients raised complaints in each of the cases referred to Greater Glasgow Health Board by the Scottish Dental Practice Division, in which the National Health Service Tribunal found Mr W. J. Duff had provided unnecessary treatment. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

What were the dates on which patients raised complaints in each of the cases referred to Greater Glasgow Health Board by the Scottish Dental Practice Division, in which the National Health Service Tribunal found Mr W. J. Duff had provided unnecessary treatment. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

If he will ensure that money received from Mr W. J. Duff by Greater Glasgow Health Board is applied directly for the benefit of his former patients. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

If he will ensure that money received from Mr W. J. Duff by Greater Glasgow Health Board is applied directly for the benefit of his former patients. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

How many patients of Mr W. J. Duff have complained to date that they were not told in advance what treatment was to be carried out by him. - One. (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

How many patients of Mr W. J. Duff have complained to date that they were not told in advance what treatment was to be carried out by him. - One. (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

What general conclusions were reached by regional dental officers from their inspections of Mr W. J. Duff's patients on 25th August 1986 and subsequently. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

What general conclusions were reached by regional dental officers from their inspections of Mr W. J. Duff's patients on 25th August 1986 and subsequently. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

How many patients were registered with Mr W. J. Duff in each year since he began practising; and what was the highest number of patients registered with any dentist in Scotland in each of these years. - Including table. (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

How many patients were registered with Mr W. J. Duff in each year since he began practising; and what was the highest number of patients registered with any dentist in Scotland in each of these years. - Including table. (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

What factors led to the inspections of Mr W. J. Duff's patients by regional dental officers on 25th August 1986. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

What factors led to the inspections of Mr W. J. Duff's patients by regional dental officers on 25th August 1986. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

If he will make a financial contribution to the voluntary support group organised by former patients of Mr W. J. Duff. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

If he will make a financial contribution to the voluntary support group organised by former patients of Mr W. J. Duff. - (Holding answer 12 March 1997).

On what date the Dental Practice Board called in regional dental officers to investigate the claims for treatment submitted by Mr William Duff; and if he will publish their report. - (Holding answer 28 January 1997).

On what date the Dental Practice Board called in regional dental officers to investigate the claims for treatment submitted by Mr William Duff; and if he will publish their report. - (Holding answer 28 January 1997).

What action he proposes to take to recover NHS payments made to William Duff between 1991 and 1995. - (Holding answer 24 January 1997).

What action he proposes to take to recover NHS payments made to William Duff between 1991 and 1995. - (Holding answer 24 January 1997).

If he will provide financial support to Greater Glasgow Health Board to organise a helpline for ex-patients of William Duff. - (Holding answer 6 February 1997).

If he will provide financial support to Greater Glasgow Health Board to organise a helpline for ex-patients of William Duff. - (Holding answer 6 February 1997).

If he will order an investigation into the handling of the case of Mr William Duff by Greater Glasgow Health Board. - (Holding answer 28 January 1997).

If he will order an investigation into the handling of the case of Mr William Duff by Greater Glasgow Health Board. - (Holding answer 28 January 1997).

On what date Greater Glasgow Health Board commenced its investigation of the fees claimed by Mr William Duff. - (Holding answer 28 January 1997).

On what date Greater Glasgow Health Board commenced its investigation of the fees claimed by Mr William Duff. - (Holding answer 28 January 1997).

What were the total earnings in fees from the NHS by Mr William Duff in each year from the time he began practising in the Greater Glasgow Health Board area. - Table given. (Holding answer 28 January 1997).

What were the total earnings in fees from the NHS by Mr William Duff in each year from the time he began practising in the Greater Glasgow Health Board area. - Table given. (Holding answer 28 January 1997).

If he will draw upon the sums relating to outstanding fee claims withheld from Mr William Duff to compensate his former patients. - (Holding answer 28 January 1997).

If he will draw upon the sums relating to outstanding fee claims withheld from Mr William Duff to compensate his former patients. - (Holding answer 28 January 1997).

What is the total number of patients who have had unnecessary treatment carried out by Mr William Duff; how many of these have had their complaint upheld and received compensation in full; how many have been refused compensation on the grounds of their being time-barred; and if he will review...

What is the total number of patients who have had unnecessary treatment carried out by Mr William Duff; how many of these have had their complaint upheld and received compensation in full; how many have been refused compensation on the grounds of their being time-barred; and if he will review...

When he expects to reply to the questions from the honourable Member for Glasgow, Maryhill of 24th and 28th January, relating to Mr. William Duff. - I replied to the hon. Member's questions today.

When he expects to reply to the questions from the honourable Member for Glasgow, Maryhill of 24th and 28th January, relating to Mr. William Duff. - I replied to the hon. Member's questions today.