Letter dated 18/09/2026 from Baroness Taylor of Stevenage to Baroness Coffey, Baroness Parminter of Godalming and Hansard Editor regarding clarification on the consultation period for Environmental Delivery Plans (EDPs), as discussed during the debate on the Nature Restoration Levy Regulations 2026. 1p.

Letter dated 18/09/2026 from Baroness Taylor of Stevenage to Baroness Coffey, Baroness Parminter of Godalming and Hansard Editor regarding clarification on the consultation period for Environmental Delivery Plans (EDPs), as discussed during the debate on the Nature Restoration Levy Regulations 2026. 1p.

Lords motion to approve. Amendment to regret agreed to on division (41 to 29). Original motion, as amended, agreed to on question.

Lords motion to approve. Amendment to regret agreed to on division (41 to 29). Original motion, as amended, agreed to on question.

My Lords, as Members will recall, the Government have been consistently clear in our commitment to get Britain building and to deliver the homes and infrastructure this country needs, but we have been equally clear that this must go hand in hand with improving outcomes for nature.

To honour that commitment,...

My Lords, as Members will recall, the Government have been consistently clear in our commitment to get Britain building and to deliver the homes and infrastructure this country needs, but we have been equally clear that this must go hand in hand with improving outcomes for nature.

To honour that commitment,...

Moved by

Lord Roborough

Moved by

Lord Roborough

My Lords, I thank the Minister for introducing these regulations. Although I am pleased to see her in her place, I wonder why they are being introduced by the Minister of State for MHCLG, when we were assured during debate that the responsible department and Secretary of State for administering...

My Lords, I thank the Minister for introducing these regulations. Although I am pleased to see her in her place, I wonder why they are being introduced by the Minister of State for MHCLG, when we were assured during debate that the responsible department and Secretary of State for administering...

My Lords, I am conscious that we spent a lot of time on the primary legislation trying to understand this, and I am not overly convinced that these regulations help. I have been carefully reading Commons Hansard, with Minister Matthew Pennycook explaining. Some things in there surprised me. It should...

My Lords, I am conscious that we spent a lot of time on the primary legislation trying to understand this, and I am not overly convinced that these regulations help. I have been carefully reading Commons Hansard, with Minister Matthew Pennycook explaining. Some things in there surprised me. It should...

My Lords, these regulations have been drawn to the special attention of the House by the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee on the basis that they are politically or legally important or are a public policy likely to be of interest. I have some points to raise. I am not necessarily...

My Lords, these regulations have been drawn to the special attention of the House by the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee on the basis that they are politically or legally important or are a public policy likely to be of interest. I have some points to raise. I am not necessarily...

My Lords, environmentalists are up in arms on the nature restoration fund and EDPs because they break the link between a development and its nature mitigations. Developers are saying that the cost, risks and delay are making development unviable, while everybody argues that nothing is getting built in those areas...

My Lords, environmentalists are up in arms on the nature restoration fund and EDPs because they break the link between a development and its nature mitigations. Developers are saying that the cost, risks and delay are making development unviable, while everybody argues that nothing is getting built in those areas...

My Lords, this discussion is the first chance that this House has had to really try to understand exactly how the Government intend to implement the new EDP process, which we debated at such considerable length during the Planning and Infrastructure Bill. As certain noble Lords have already said, these...

My Lords, this discussion is the first chance that this House has had to really try to understand exactly how the Government intend to implement the new EDP process, which we debated at such considerable length during the Planning and Infrastructure Bill. As certain noble Lords have already said, these...

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Taylor of Stevenage, for her introduction to these regulations and my noble friend Lord Roborough for his amendment and thoughtful words. I also thank other noble Lords who participated in this debate for their thoughtful words. I think there is universal agreement...

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Taylor of Stevenage, for her introduction to these regulations and my noble friend Lord Roborough for his amendment and thoughtful words. I also thank other noble Lords who participated in this debate for their thoughtful words. I think there is universal agreement...

My Lords, I am grateful to all noble Lords for their considered contributions. It has been a useful debate, but some of it has reflected some of the issues that we rehearsed in the Planning and Infrastructure Bill and has not focused as much on the regulations. I will try...

My Lords, I am grateful to all noble Lords for their considered contributions. It has been a useful debate, but some of it has reflected some of the issues that we rehearsed in the Planning and Infrastructure Bill and has not focused as much on the regulations. I will try...

Before the Minister sits down, can I just clarify a couple of comments that she made? She was very clear that there would be an option as to whether one went with the Natural England EDP. Can we be absolutely clear that that will always be the case, particularly when...

Before the Minister sits down, can I just clarify a couple of comments that she made? She was very clear that there would be an option as to whether one went with the Natural England EDP. Can we be absolutely clear that that will always be the case, particularly when...

I will clarify that, in all but exceptional circumstances, EDPs are voluntary for developers. The Planning and Infrastructure Act establishes that Natural England can recommend that use of an EDP be mandatory only where it deems it to be necessary. This is a high legal bar, and it would ultimately...

I will clarify that, in all but exceptional circumstances, EDPs are voluntary for developers. The Planning and Infrastructure Act establishes that Natural England can recommend that use of an EDP be mandatory only where it deems it to be necessary. This is a high legal bar, and it would ultimately...

My Lords, I am very grateful to all noble Lords who have spoken in this short debate. I will clarify one point made by my noble friend Lord Randall. I hope no one thinks I am speaking on behalf of developers; I am speaking on behalf of nature. My concern...

My Lords, I am very grateful to all noble Lords who have spoken in this short debate. I will clarify one point made by my noble friend Lord Randall. I hope no one thinks I am speaking on behalf of developers; I am speaking on behalf of nature. My concern...

Motion to consider. Agreed to on question.

Motion to consider. Agreed to on question.

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, what is the evidential basis for determining that there is a clear need for Environmental Delivery Plans; whether that evidence will be published; and what assessment she has made of the value for money of Environmental Delivery Plans.

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, what is the evidential basis for determining that there is a clear need for Environmental Delivery Plans; whether that evidence will be published; and what assessment she has made of the value for money of Environmental Delivery Plans.

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, when the Government plans to publish its assessment of the effectiveness of Environmental Delivery Plans; what criteria will be used to evaluate their success; and whether further Environmental Delivery Plans will be introduced only following publication of that...

To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, when the Government plans to publish its assessment of the effectiveness of Environmental Delivery Plans; what criteria will be used to evaluate their success; and whether further Environmental Delivery Plans will be introduced only following publication of that...