Skip to main content

Business question from David Heath (Liberal Democrat) in the House of Commons on Thursday, 25 January 2007. It occurred during Business statement on Business of the House.


Business of the House

I am sure the Leader of the House is familiar with the practice in restaurants of putting little symbols on the menu to show which dishes are suitable for vegetarians, for coeliacs and so on. Will he consider a similar system for the Order Paper, so that debates are clearly marked as being suitable for the Prime Minister? Before yesterday’s debate, we were told at different points by the Prime Minister’s spokesmen that he does not do Back-Bench debates—apparently, a debate in Government time opened by the Foreign Secretary is a Back-Bench debate—that he does not do foreign affairs debates, and then that he never attends such debates, whatever the topic may be. May we be assured that there are at least some debates that the Prime Minister would feel it appropriate to attend, rather than chumming up to the CBI? Perhaps one of them might be a debate on four years of war in which brave British soldiers are being killed on every day of every week. May we have a debate on the air passenger duty, which was raised by the hon. Member for North-West Cambridgeshire (Mr. Vara) in Chancellor’s questions? Not only are there questions about the implementation, but practical difficulties. The Leader of the House knows that we support a tax on aviation, although we support a tax on the pollution caused by planes, rather than on the passengers who travel in them. Is it not the case that because the duty is retrospective, it will cause chaos in our airports and great difficulties for both travellers and airlines, as well as huge financial disadvantage to tour operators? A tour operator in my constituency, Gerry Copsey, points out in a letter to me that the tour operator has to absorb the first 2 per cent. of any surcharge, which he has not collected because the tax did not exist. That is therefore a direct and substantial windfall tax on tour operators. It cannot be right, and the House should have the opportunity to debate it. Last week the President of the United States gave the ““State of the Union”” address. May we have a debate on the state of the Union—in this case, the Act of Union between Scotland and England? There we could explore the huge advantages to both Scotland and England of the Union, we could address those who wish to split us asunder on any basis, some explicitly and some implicitly, and we could look at the ways in which we could improve the Union to ensure that every part of the Union feels that it has a fair voice. Lastly, on written questions—a matter which I often ask the Leader of the House to look into—my hon. Friend the Member for Bath (Mr. Foster) last week asked the Department for Culture, Media and Sport how many libraries closed in London. The reply from the Department was that it could not provide the information because"““focusing on the number of closures is less helpful as a measure of overall provision than the net number of public library service points in each year””—[Official Report, 23 January 2007; Vol. 455, c. 1620W.]—" in other words, Departments now want to provide not only the answers, but the questions. Will the right hon. Gentleman remind his colleagues that we ask the questions and they are supposed to answer?


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
455 c1557-9 
Session
2006-07
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Related items
Business of the House
Thursday, 25 January 2007
Proceeding contributions
House of Commons
Business of the House
Thursday, 25 January 2007
Proceeding contributions
House of Commons
Subjects
Aviation Administrative delays Debates Taxation Written questions Blair, Tony
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk