---

National Insurance Contributions Bill

I am following the hon. Gentleman’s remarks closely. First, perhaps he can explain how the retrospection for NICs will be different from that which we already have for tax. Secondly, may I point out to him that not many people on minimum wage in my constituency have been getting paid in platinum sponges or any such device? I would expect most people, if not all, who will be caught by this legislation to have had specialist tax advice, quite possibly through their employer. That specialist tax adviser should have told them that anything after 2 December 2004 is at risk. If the tax adviser failed to do so, he or she is at risk in respect of negligence.