Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Foster of Bath (Liberal Democrat) in the House of Commons on Wednesday, 14 December 2005. It occurred during Adjournment debate on UK World Heritage Sites.


UK World Heritage Sites

: The hon. Gentleman may doubt the speed, but he knows that with the new franchise, we have a commitment from First Group to provide better rolling stock on the line. Perhaps the hon. Member for Middlesbrough, South and East Cleveland and my hon. Friend the Member for East Dunbartonshire (Jo Swinson), who is no longer present, were guilty of trying to put too many sites on the tentative list. Now that we have the opportunity for only one key proposal, it will be even more difficult for GWR to be the one that we take forward. Wherever world heritage sites are—Saltaire, Telford or anywhere else—we are proud of them, we know about their importance, we recognise their economic potential and we know that they are attractive to businesses and investment. After all, they have been singled out as the best examples in the world of places that people inhabit, visit and so on. I recognise the enormous benefit of that status, but it does not alter the fact that there are a number of problems, which other hon. Members have already described. Bath, for example, has a large number of listed buildings. The people in listed buildings automatically have to apply for listed building consent to make any changes, but they do not have to pay for that, which puts financial pressure on the local authority. Because Bath is a world heritage city, if there is a major development and the developers come in, our local council planning department must do a huge amount of additional work. However, there is a cap on the amount of money that it can charge developers, which creates a huge strain. Throughout the country, there is inconsistency in the funding, back-up and support for our 26 world heritages sites. Sadly, there are gaps in the conservation legislation and the listed building and scheduled monument legislation, down which we can fall. There are huge pressures. The South West regional assembly, in developing its regional spatial plan, wants to create a huge amount of growth in Bath. There are huge consequences for the way in which we manage that growth while retaining the uniqueness that entitles us to call ourselves a world heritage city. We must find a way of resolving that conflict. Only in the past couple of days, I received a letter from Bath's conservation officer with responsibility for world heritage. She writes:"““It is very hard to get environmental issues such as World Heritage status appropriately considered in the face of ‘economic necessity', especially when we are talking about emotive (as well as essential) issues such as affordable housing and employment. But, and it's a big but, certainly with Bath and with most if not all other World Heritage Sites, we will be killing the golden goose if we allow inappropriate levels and types of development.””" She is absolutely right. We must find solutions to that problem. As the hon. Member for Telford said, management plans are part of the solution. This country led the way in putting them in place. Now, nearly all our world heritage sites have one, and soon all of them will. They are part of the way forward. However, unless we find resources for implementing them, we will be in difficulty, as the hon. Member for Shipley rightly said. We must also take forward some of the other ideas that have been suggested. The Government are currently conducting a heritage protection review. Many of us would urge the Minister to provide statutory protection in one form or another for world heritage sites, and to ensure that it is the right sort of statutory protection. This cannot be done on some sort of consensual basis. A mandatory system must be put in place to get real protection. Perhaps the Minister will respond to those points. As has been mentioned, there have been opportunities in respect of the register of historic sites and buildings and so on, but there are models—for example, areas of outstanding natural beauty and the Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2000—that we could pick up and run with quickly. I am conscious that time is tight, so I must finish soon. In his extremely valuable contribution, the hon. Member for Telford discussed the need to start promoting the brand in this country, and he is absolutely right. My suggestions build on what he said. There are five key steps that we could easily take. First, we should work hard to get all the United Kingdom's sites to use and prominently display the official world heritage symbol. Secondly, Ordnance Survey maps should show world heritage sites with the appropriate symbol on all its maps. Thirdly, VisitBritain should promote our world heritage sites much more effectively, particularly when it advertises overseas. Fourthly, let us persuade every site to distribute a leaflet that describes what is offered at the other sites in the rest of the country and overseas. Finally, let us find better ways of providing links between the sites—perhaps route maps and so on. I entirely agree with the hon. Member for Telford that the 2012 Olympics will provide a target date for putting all those ideas in place. World heritage sites are fantastic. They are wonderful. We should be enormously proud of the 26 in this country, but they need more help, and I hope that in few minutes' time the Minister will describe how he will provide it.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
440 c473-5WH 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
Westminster Hall
Subjects
Access Conservation Ancient monuments Cultural heritage Archaeological sites Planning UNESCO World Heritage sites Stonehenge Hadrian's Wall Ironbridge Gorge
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk