Proceeding contribution from Lord Sainsbury of Turville (Labour) in the House of Lords on Wednesday, 11 January 2006. It occurred during Debate on bill on Company Law Reform Bill [HL] 2005-06.
Company Law Reform Bill [HL]
My Lords, we will certainly reflect on that. There are perceived difficulties with that approach, but we will certainly reflect on that and then propose any changes using the proposed reform power in the Bill. I now turn to the reform power, which is clearly a major issue in the Bill and an extremely difficult one. It may be useful to go over the underlying rationale for the proposed company law reform power. As I said, it is usual these days in technically complex areas of law to leave the detail of the provisions to subordinate legislation, but company law has grown over the centuries and many of even its most detailed provisions are written in primary legislation. That creates a challenge when updating the law to reflect a changing business environment. Although it may be relatively easy to secure parliamentary time for a Bill where a change of the law is essential, it can be more difficult in cases where the proposed reform is useful and desirable but where existing law can, at a pinch, limp along as it is. An interesting example of that is the 1989 court case known as Aveling Barford, which cast doubt on when a company can make an intra-group transfer of assets at book value. The Bill removes those doubts. That is an example of where it has taken a long time to get parliamentary time. We recognise that the power that we have suggested raises important issues. We have designed it as a super-affirmative power, incorporating stringent conditions as to how it can be used, including extensive requirements for public consultation and parliamentary scrutiny. To a large extent, those requirements reflect the existing arrangements of the Regulatory Reform Act 2001 and are intended to provide demonstrable and effective safeguards surrounding what can undoubtedly be seen as a very wide and novel power. Notwithstanding those safeguards, important concerns have been raised. As I said, the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee and the chairman of the Constitution Committee raised a number of such concerns and make some powerful arguments. Those committees always, rightly, command the greatest respect in this House and it is important that we reflect on their comments and those that the noble Viscount, Lord Bledisloe, made this afternoon. We consider them seriously; I assure the House that the Government are doing exactly that. I believe that the underlying rationale behind the proposal remains compelling. We very much want to achieve an effective and constitutionally appropriate mechanism for necessary changes in future. I hope that we will be able to find such a way through, which can command the support of the House. I have already found today’s debate hugely informative and I look forward to further debates that I am sure we shall have at the Bill’s next stage. I remark on two points that were raised in connection with that. The noble Lord, Lord Sharman, asked whether reform powers will require affirmative resolution and whether consultation will be wide. I can confirm that, in addition to the special period for parliamentary scrutiny in which we envisage that Special Committees of both Houses will scrutinise proposals in detail, the Bill also provides for affirmative resolution of orders. I also reassure the noble Lord that full statutory consultation will be necessary before a proposal is made, involving representative interests likely to be substantially affected. My noble friend Lord Clinton-Davis raised the question of the Government needing to take account of consultation before bringing forward a company law reform order. The Minister will need not just to take account of consultation but, as is clear from Clause 785, to summarise the outcome and what account has been taken of it in the document, which we would have to lay before Parliament. I think that I dealt with the question of consolidation in my opening speech and explained why that is rather a mythical goal to be striving for. We could take the capital maintenance regulations of the 1985 Act and consolidate them in the Bill. That would change some of its wording, which people do not want to see—particularly in view of the fact that, almost certainly, a new Bill will have to come forward with capital maintenance regulations. So, even if we consolidated it briefly now and made people look at some new legislation, we would then simply have an unconsolidated Bill as soon as we brought in the capital maintenance. I cannot see that this is a particularly profitable way to do it. When we push people on this issue we find that everyone is in favour of consolidation, ““but not in my lifetime””. That is a perfectly understandable proposition. But, when it comes to the crunch, you have got to make a decision, and we think we are reflecting what people really want to see. I believe that there is general agreement about the many issues in the Bill although there are some concerns about particular matters. I also believe it is largely a technical Bill and not controversial in party terms. Nevertheless, company law represents a balance of different interests—this has been reflected in the points of difference that have been raised today—and the Government’s responsibility is to provide a legal framework which reconciles these interests and provides a means of accountability for the exercise of corporate economic power and the safeguards and remedies for abuses of that power. It is an important Bill which will help to ensure that our company regulation and financial markets continue to be regarded as amongst the best in the world. I look forward to detailed debate in Committee. On Question, Bill read a second time, and committed to a Grand Committee.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 677 c247-9
- Session
- 2005-06
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords chamber
- Subjects
- Codes of practice Charities Audit Accountancy Company law Company accounts Companies Directors Fraud Finance ICT Liability Environment Donors EU law Information Pensions Political parties Meetings Registration Small businesses Shares Reform Shareholders Takeovers
- Legislation
- Companies Act 1985
- Companies Act 1989
- Company Law Reform Bill (HL) 2005-06
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2024-04-21 21:26:10 +0100
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_290436
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_290436
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_290436