Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Baroness Walmsley (Liberal Democrat) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 14 February 2006. It occurred during Ministerial statement on Child Protection: Shaken Baby Syndrome.


Child Protection: Shaken Baby Syndrome

My Lords, I thank the noble and learned Lord the Attorney-General for repeating the Statement. Unlike the noble Earl, Lord Howe, I did not have the advantage of having a copy of the review, but I do not hold the noble and learned Lord responsible for that. Unlike the noble Earl, I do not intend to concentrate on medical details. The Court of Appeal has the advantage over me in that respect, having pulled together the evidence of the 25 leading experts. However, I have some questions on the very helpful Statement which tells us what the Government intend to do. On the process of the review, was there a thorough review of all the paperwork from beginning to end, including all the evidence and statements, and not just the CPS notes of the case? On page 4 of the Statement, the noble and learned Lord said:"““In the considerable majority of the remaining SBS cases, other extraneous evidence existed to support the findings of shaken baby syndrome””." Does that mean that in a minority of the 85 cases, there was no extraneous evidence apart from the medical evidence? Why does that justify not considering that those cases gave cause for concern? We need to ensure that there is justice for parents and justice for children. Sadly, it is known that in a very few cases, parents do harm their children. So it is vital that there are no presumptions whatever. Courts should come to their conclusions solely on the basis of the evidence before them, much of which will inevitably come from expert witnesses who must not see themselves as advocates for one side or the other. They must give their evidence impartially, based on their expertise in their field. I very much welcome the guidance which the Government have prepared for them. But what guidance will be given to the courts on the advice that juries should be given on how to view the evidence and the credibility of those experts? On page 5 of the Statement, the noble and learned Lord said that the experts,"““will also be required to certify that they have revealed to the prosecution any information that might adversely affect their credibility””." What happens to the experts if they are subsequently found not to have done that? Finally, how would the measures that the noble and learned Lord has announced today have affected the cases of Sally Clark, Angela Cannings and Trupti Patel? That is their acid test.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
678 c1084 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Disclosure of information Carers Convictions Babies Court of Appeal Doctors Infanticide Judgements Parents Miscarriages of justice Trials Reviews Cot deaths Expert evidence
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk