Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Wednesday, 15 March 2006. It occurred during Debate on bill and Committee proceeding on Company Law Reform Bill (HL).


Company Law Reform Bill

moved Amendment No. A14:"Page 251, line 1, leave out subsection (4)." The noble Lord said: I thank the Chairman for congratulating us on our stamina; we are only just getting going. This amendment in part touches on the issues raised by the noble Lord, Lord Sharman, in the previous group, which we discussed yesterday evening, led by Amendment No. A10. We have taken a slightly different approach, which is to strike out the whole of Clause 526(4) on a probing basis. We do so because we argue that the clause needs to be redrafted if it is to achieve what we believe the Government want to achieve. First, the exemptions in this subsection and subsection (5) would not include the directors of the company if they were not also employees, as they are neither,"““persons already connected with the company””," under subsection (4)(a), nor eligible to participate in an ““employees’ share scheme”” as defined in Section 743 of the Companies Act 1985, which is not being repealed. There is a further problem. If the company’s articles permit certain transfers to non-members—for example, intra-group, or to family members and trusts—can the requirement that the offer cannot properly be regarded,"““as being calculated to result . . . in securities of the company becoming available to persons not already connected with the company””," be satisfied? One issue is that closely held companies with pre-emption rights disapply these with regard to family trusts as a means to maintain family ownership by bridging the generation gap. Trusts may be set up for one reason or another and the pre-emption rights are disapplied as far as those are concerned. What is the meaning of ““calculated””? The Minister was very helpful about that in our discussions last night, when he said:"““The Oxford English Dictionary defines ‘calculated to’ as ‘designed or suitable, intended’””.—[Official Report, 14/3/06; col. GC462.]" There is not a huge difference between us, so we will not advance this much further. Our question is whether there needs to be an intent on the part of an existing member to retain the shares, which the company has to have warranted to it, or whether the fact that the articles include committed transfer provisions is sufficient to satisfy the ““calculated”” test, which is feasible since the shares are offered subject to the articles of association. Moving on from ““calculated””, what about the definition of ““connected”” in the family trusts example that I have used? That is important, as these circumstances are prevalent in the case of family and closely held companies. A third and final argument exists if the articles contain standard pre-emption rights on transfer. If the offer round is not taken up, the shares can go to third parties. Obviously, to protect the rights of a vendor shareholder, the articles will often permit external transfers if internal transfers cannot be fulfilled; otherwise the vendor would effectively be locked in because of the nature of the articles. Again, does this satisfy the ““calculated”” test, or is it a subjective test at the time of the share issue? This does not sit with the concept of the absolute presumption introduced in Clause 525, which we discussed earlier in the group of amendments beginning with Amendment No. A1. These are practical issues which have been raised with us by City practitioners. It would be helpful if the Minister could explain further the practical implications of the operation of Clause 526(4). On a probing basis, we seek to remove it for the time being. I beg to move.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
679 c467-8GC 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Company law Companies Directors Exemptions Staff Private companies Registration Shares Shareholders
Legislation
Company Law Reform Bill (HL) 2005-06
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk