Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord McKenzie of Luton (Labour) in the House of Lords on Wednesday, 15 March 2006. It occurred during Debate on bill and Committee proceeding on Company Law Reform Bill (HL).


Company Law Reform Bill

Like subsection (3), this subsection is derived from Section 742A of the Companies Act 1985. It creates an exemption for offers to persons already connected with the company. This recognises the way in which private companies may grow organically. It makes it clear that offers to family members are not to be regarded as offers to the public. Such offers are unlikely to be public offers in any event, but the subsection creates an exemption for offers to members of the company, employees and debenture holders. We believe that directors will be persons connected with the company if they are members or employees. I would have thought that that would routinely be the case, as in existing law. These could amount to a very large number of people, but nevertheless this would not be treated as an offer to the public, provided that the particular requirements are met. In order to make an offer to persons already connected with the company using the exemption in subsection (4), two particular requirements must be met. The first is that, if the offer is made on terms allowing the person to whom it is made to renounce their rights, those rights may only be renounced in favour of another person so connected. This refers to where an offer is made, giving someone the right to take up shares or debentures, but allowing that right to be transferred to another person. That is not just about, as indicated in the discussion that we had yesterday, preventing there being rights to transfer the shares; it is also a question of what consent was planned at the time the offer was made. This right may be valuable if it is a right to an allotment of shares or an issue of debentures at a discount to their current value. But subsection (4) is an exemption for offers made to persons already connected with the company, and so if the right to take up the offer is transferable, it should be transferable only to someone else who is already connected with the company. Section 742A of the Companies Act 1985 currently imposes the same requirement. The second requirement is that the offer cannot properly be regarded, in all the circumstances, as being calculated—this amendment seeks to probe the definition of ““calculated””—to result, directly or indirectly, in securities of the company becoming available to persons not already connected with the company. We see that as an objective test. It replaces the provisions of Section 742A of the Companies Act, which treated an offer to persons connected with the company as being a domestic concern of the persons making and receiving it, unless the contrary was proved. ““Connected””, as I tried to outline in some detail yesterday, is an objective test, and I refer the noble Lord to Hansard. I hoped to deal with the matter as clearly as I was able. The purpose is to ensure that the exemption is not misused to make shares available to persons falling outside the exemption. We therefore believe that the subsection is necessary, and I hope that the noble Lord will not press his amendment. If I have not dealt with each of the points that he raised, perhaps he will prompt me again and I will endeavour to do so.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
679 c468-9GC 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Company law Companies Directors Exemptions Staff Private companies Registration Shares Shareholders
Legislation
Company Law Reform Bill (HL) 2005-06
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk