Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Rix (Crossbench) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 2 May 2006. It occurred during Debate on bill and Committee proceeding on Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Bill [HL].


Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Bill [HL]

moved Amendment No. 14:"Page 1, line 8, leave out paragraphs (a) and (b) and insert ““the children’s and adults’ barred list””" The noble Lord said: I appear to be giving a solo performance with my Amendments Nos. 14 and 16 for, although Amendments Nos. 15, 17 and 55 support them in essence, they are slightly dissimilar to mine. They envisage two separate lists with a crossover point whereas mine would bring the two proposed lists—the children’s barred list and the adults’ barred lists—together into a single children and adults’ barred list. The reason is straightforward and can be simply stated: if it is not safe for someone to work with children, because of a risk of abuse, then it is not safe for them to work with vulnerable adults. Abuse of both children and adults, of whatever kind, involves breaking trust and imposing power over the vulnerable. People prepared to do that have no place in sensitive settings in which vulnerable people of any age are placed. The research into sexual abuse of elderly people conducted by the Ann Craft Trust was mentioned a number of times at Second Reading, but I hope I will be permitted to raise it briefly again. It showed that one in five who sexually abused older people had also sexually abused children. It also said that, in some cases, the professionals saw the linking factor as a belief in the unlikelihood of disclosure, while, in others, the offender was seen as willing to break any moral boundaries. I hope that noble Lords will agree with me that those who think that they can get away with abuse, and are willing to break moral boundaries, have no place working with vulnerable people—adults or children. At Second Reading, the Minister said that it would be disproportionate for a person who had been barred from working with vulnerable adults because of financial fraud to be barred from working in all positions with children. There are several responses to that. First, a person guilty of financial fraud pertaining to vulnerable adults is hardly a proper role model for children, or a safe person to work with them. If someone has committed fraud, he has broken trust for his own gain and may have caused direct harm to the interests of the vulnerable adults he worked with. How are we to know that he will not do so again? Or, if we think we do know, why are we more confident about him than we are about another ex-offender? That is quite apart from the fact that there are many jobs with children—teaching, for example—that involve handling finances and that we might prefer fraudsters not to do. Secondly, if it is disproportionate for a person who has committed financial fraud to be barred from working in all positions with children, why is it not disproportionate for him to be barred from working in all positions with adults too? There are plenty of jobs one could get working with vulnerable adults that involve no financial matters whatsoever. Why does the Minister think that it is proportionate to bar fraudsters from them, but not from non-financial jobs with children? Either financial fraud is relevant to non-financial work with vulnerable people, or it is irrelevant. It cannot be both. The third response takes seriously the Minister’s words at Second Reading, when he said that he agreed that,"““no individuals should have the right to work with children: it is a privilege. Individuals should be able to give full assurances of their good conduct and safety in so doing. I take that to apply in full measure to the vulnerable adults who the noble Lord, Lord Rix, rightly highlighted in his discussions””.—[Official Report, 28/3/06; col. 755.]" I agree with the Minister in his agreement with me and with other noble Lords. Working with vulnerable people is a privilege and not a right. Nobody has a right to a privilege: that is why it is called a privilege and not a right. I hope that those welcome words by the Minister will be taken seriously by anyone who seeks to claim that he has a right under the Human Rights Act to work with children or vulnerable adults. Given that a single list would provide more protection and less inconsistency, and would respect the Minister’s belief that nobody has the right to work with vulnerable people, it would be more appropriate to have a single barred list than two barred lists. I beg to move. [The Sitting was suspended for a Division in the House from 4.17 to 4.29 pm]


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
681 c170-1GC 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Disability Children Disclosure of information Codes of practice Abuse Appeals Costs Advisory services Finance Human rights Internet Personal records Protection Membership Public appointments Older people Mental capacity Vetting Vulnerable adults Sexual offences Independent Safeguarding Authority
Legislation
Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Bill (HL) 2005-06
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk