Maiden speech from Lord Krebs (Crossbench) in the House of Lords on Friday, 8 June 2007. It occurred during Debate on bill on Television Advertising (Food) Bill [HL].
Television Advertising (Food) Bill [HL]
My Lords, it is a great honour to address this House for the first time. I start by thanking the staff your Lordships’ House, as well as my fellow Peers, for the warm and helpful welcome that I have received. Some have suggested that my academic background as a zoologist studying the behaviour of animals and as an ecologist acquainted with endangered species will equip me exceptionally well for work in the House! However, today’s debate links to my time as chairman of the Food Standards Agency. In July 2004, the agency published a wide-ranging action plan for improving children’s diets. It included the recommendation to Ofcom and the food industry that the promotion and advertising of food, including soft drinks, to children should reflect a healthy diet. As we have already heard, the National Diet and Nutrition Survey shows that the average child in this country has an unbalanced diet. Put simply, he or she eats too much fat, salt and sugar and not enough fruit and vegetables. Again as we have already heard, a poor diet is bad for a child’s health, and it contributes to the rapidly rising prevalence of obesity in children. The last Health Survey for England recorded that 25 per cent of children between the ages of 11 and 14 were obese—an increase from 14 per cent a mere 10 years earlier. We know that these children are likely to suffer many health problems in the future, and most of us would agree that we have a duty of care to protect children and support their parents in their responsibility in looking after their kids’ diets. The Bill introduced by the noble Baroness, Lady Thornton, aims to implement a specific recommendation made by the Food Standards Agency of a nine o’clock watershed for television advertising of foods high in fat, salt and sugar. I want to focus on just one question: how robust is the evidence to support the propositions in the Bill? There are two parts to that question. First, is there evidence that TV advertising affects children’s diets and, secondly, is there a proper scientific basis for discriminating between ““healthy”” and ““less healthy”” foods? As is often the case in the interface between science and policy, the underpinning science does not provide us with clean, crisp answers, so it is not surprising that there is much heated debate about both issues. That makes it all the more important to stand back and take an impartial view, following the advice of James McNeill Whistler, who famously said: "““I maintain that two and two would continue to make four, in spite of the whine of the amateur for three, or the cry of the critic for five””." So does the evidence on the effect of TV advertising add up? As we have heard, children’s diets are influenced by many factors and it is hard to separate out their relative importance. But the Food Standards Agency’s systematic review of the evidence—the so-called Hastings review—showed that advertising food does have a significant influence on children’s diets. It influences not just brand preference (Mars versus KitKat) but diet as a whole—chocolate versus vegetables. That conclusion is now widely accepted by experts in the field. Indeed, the claim that advertising has no effect invites the retort, ““Why does the industry spend£300 million a year doing it?””. Moreover, since the food industry is in favour of government advertising campaigns to promote positive messages about healthy eating, such as ““5 a day””, they must surely assume that such promotion and marketing has an effect on children’s diets. The Hastings review concluded that the direct effect of TV advertising on children’s diets may be small. The science is not really precise enough to put numbers on it. But Hastings also concluded that there is a much larger indirect effect of advertising; for instance, through children’s classmates or parents. Any parent who has experienced pester power does not need to be further convinced of this. Advertising undermines their attempts to steer their kids towards a healthy diet. My second question is whether there is a scientific definition of healthy and less healthy food? In this context, the term ““junk food”” is often bandied about, but it is not a scientific term and, in my view, it is not helpful. How do you decide, apart from by personal prejudice, what is a junk food and what is not? There is, however, a more objective basis for separating foods into healthy and less healthy, starting from the science of nutrition. The Food Standards Agency has developed a model of nutrient profiles for foods, a way of combining the positive and negative nutritional aspects of a processed composite food, such as a pizza, into a single score. So the nutrients that children tend to eat too much of—fat, sugar and salt—count as negatives, while the nutrients that are underrepresented in children’s diets—components such as fruit, vegetables, protein and fibre—are counted as positives. There is no precise formula for combining these components into a single score, so an elementof judgment is involved. Therefore, the resulting categorisation of foods into healthy and less healthy can be no more than an approximation, but it is based on the best available scientific evidence. This nutrient profile model has been criticised by some in the food industry because they are surprised that certain products, such as hard cheese, come out as ““less healthy””. But surely this is putting prejudice before science. It is saying, as perhaps Galileo experienced, ““The science is defeating my prejudice; therefore I accept prejudice and reject the science””. I, for one, would rather follow a scientific analysis than one based on preconceptions. The Food Standards Agency’s model has, as we have heard, been adopted by Ofcom in the restrictions on TV advertising now being introduced. The noble Baroness’s Bill is based on the proposition that Ofcom’s proposals do not go far enough; that they do not strike the right balance between health benefits to children and costs to the advertising and broadcast industries. This is a judgment about the proportionality of regulation. The argument for going further, as we have heard, is that more children watch programmes not covered by the Ofcom restrictions than watch the ones that are covered. A 9 pm watershed, as proposed in the Bill, would capture most of the programmes that children watch. How effective would such a ban be? A recent Australian study, comparing a range of possible measures to tackle childhood obesity, including stomach stapling, concluded that restricting TV advertising of less healthy food and drink to children is the single most cost-effective population-level public health intervention to tackle childhood obesity. As the noble Baroness, Lady Buscombe, has pointed out, while the tight restrictions proposed in the Bill are not going to transform our children’s diets on their own, they should form part of a wider strategy to change the food culture in this country. We have heard comments about the importance of exercise. Exercise is important, but bear in mind a simple fact: if you go to the gym and run for 30 minutes flat out on the treadmill, step off the treadmill and drink a single can of Coke, you will have put on all the calories that you had burnt off in that 30 minutes. It is difficult to burn off calories by exercise. As we have heard, recent opinion polls show that more parents are in favour of a 9 pm watershed than are against it. Some will argue that this is taking the nanny state too far, but the major challenge of childhood obesity will not be solved without significant action by government. What is more, as the noble Baroness, Lady Thomas of Walliswood, has mentioned, there will be a further benefit of tightening the restrictions: they will drive innovation in the food industry. As the chairman of one our largest food companies said to me two years ago, the race is on to create new products that come under the bar in terms of high fat, salt and sugar. The first companies to develop those products will market them furiously to our children and thereby help them to eat a healthier diet. If we are to wait and see if Ofcom’s measures produce thinner children over the years, we will be waiting for a very long time indeed. I support this Bill. It has a sound scientific basis and it will make a difference to the health of the nation.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 692 c1369-72
- Session
- 2006-07
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords chamber
- Subjects
- Advertising Food Nutrition Standards Television
- Legislation
- Television Advertising (Food) Bill (HL) 2006-07
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2024-07-16 14:58:34 +0100
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_401625
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_401625
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_401625