Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Mitchell (Labour) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 12 June 2007. It occurred during Question for short debate on Universities: Anti-Semitism.


Universities: Anti-Semitism

My Lords, I declare an interest as chairman of Weizmann UK. The Weizmann Institute of Science is located in Israel and is concerned with the development of basic science. It is one of the foremost institutes of its type in the world. I was there last week. The topic of the proposed UCU boycott was hot news, as noble Lords would expect. The institute is nationally blind. Scientists come there from all over the world;4 some are Muslim, including Israeli Arabs and Palestinians. All that matters is the science. One professor said to me: "““Don’t they realise that the nucleus of the Peace Now movement is located on campuses just like this? Do not they see we are fighting first-hand the same cause as they are and that they claim to espouse from the comforts of their armchairs? I am the one who battles with the authorities to get my Palestinian students here. I deal with the roadblocks and the identity checks. What do they do?””." The proposed boycott is bad for science. It counters the very concept of science, which is about absolute truth and academic freedom. The boycott is also bad for the Palestinians and their desire for nationhood. All that it does is alienate their friends and supporters in Israel and give comfort to their enemies. They have chosen the wrong target. The proposed boycott is bad for Britain. Boycotts beget boycotts. Two can play at that game, perhaps even three. Israeli academics can equally boycott the UK. If that were to happen—heaven forbid—academics in both countries would be the losers. I now hear rumblings that, if British universities boycott Israeli universities, American universities will boycott ours. Is that what the UCU wants? More to the point, is it what our universities want?


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
692 c1667-8 
Session
2006-07
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Jews Higher education Freedom of expression Racial discrimination Race relations Racial harassment Universities Religious hatred Students Student unions Sanctions Israel Antisemitism All-Party Parliamentary Group Against Antisemitism
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk