Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Peter Luff (Conservative) in the House of Commons on Thursday, 29 November 2007. It occurred during Adjournment debate on Post Office Restructuring.


Post Office Restructuring

As always, the hon. Lady makes a powerful and important point, and I can only agree with her. I shall rush through my remaining questions to give hon. Members a chance to make their contributions. Will the Minister outline progress on Commission approval for the £1.7 billion support package for 2007-11? We welcome the pledge in principle to continue the social network payment beyond 2011, which is now enshrined in Government promises. However, another £750 million in the package has not been properly explained, so will the Minister clarify what the rest of the state aid package is? Can he confirm the view that has been expressed here that the network subsidy scheme will spread the subsidy more thinly, because it now covers urban and rural post offices, whereas it previously covered only rural offices? A modest request is to ask him if he will please at least commit to ensure that support will rise in line with inflation during the period that it applies. Briefly, we do not want a permanently subsidised network; we want a viable network that stands on its own feet, and that is common ground on both sides. The Post Office Ltd business needs more imagination and entrepreneurialism than it has shown so far. To be fair, the new managing director, Alan Cook, is doing precisely that, and I welcome many of his initiatives, such as that on life assurance, and the effective TV advertising campaign, but I am concerned about the inhibitions still being placed on sub-postmasters and what they can do in their own shops. There are sharp issues concerning Paypoint. Many of my constituents were upset to lose the ability to go to their post office to pay their television licence, for example. There are some difficult issues, and Royal Mail Group has taken a one-sided approach. Another important point—the last one before I sit down—is to ask the Minister to bring us up to date with the Post Office card account tendering process. What is going on? We remain disappointed by the apparently limited functionality that the new card will offer. At least the mistakes could be corrected, which was not so with the original Post Office card account. This is a big opportunity to bring big new custom to the Post Office, but that opportunity is not being seized. I hope that the tenders offer some imaginative ideas, and I hope that the Post Office tender will win. We must recognise the risk that it may not do so. The loss of the Post Office card account to the network would be a devastating, perhaps even fatal, blow. I have raised many questions for the Minister, and I have spoken for far longer than I wanted—I suspect that my speech has lasted as long as I planned, but responses to interventions took up more time. I shall repeat this one question: how big can the network be and still meet the Government's access criteria? This is the first stage, I fear, of a continuing process by which there will be more and more closures. The Government can hide behind the access criteria and say simply, ““We are meeting our criteria and we do not have to plug the gap””, but that would be very serious indeed. The fundamental strength of the network—its size, depth, breadth and reach—gives it a great deal of power in the marketplace. I am grateful to hon. Members for their constructive contributions and I look forward to the rest of the debate.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
468 c144-5WH 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
Westminster Hall
Subjects
Access Cost effectiveness Closures Government assistance Public participation Post offices
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk