Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Russell Brown (Labour) in the House of Commons on Thursday, 29 November 2007. It occurred during Adjournment debate on Post Office Restructuring.


Post Office Restructuring

I shall be brief. I wish to share with colleagues the experiences in my constituency after a rural postal pilot that ran from September 2005 to 2006. We have a major challenge before us. We are dealing with a historic network that grew over many years. As I showed earlier when I intervened on the hon. Member for Argyll and Bute (Mr. Reid), people in today's world conduct their business differently. It was astonishing to discover that, despite the fact that their village still had a rural post office, people chose not to use it because it was more convenient to use the facility in the supermarket when they did their shopping. The way that people conduct their business creates a constant battle. Initially, during the rural postal pilot in my constituency—the outreach or hub and spoke system, as it was described—there were some difficulties with the computer equipment and intermittent disruption to service in the three village shops, which was managed by a sub-postmistress from the town of Castle Douglas. There was great anger in one of the villages. I attended a public meeting last January and was deeply concerned that the whole system might fall apart, but there was good intent. The hours of three village sub-post offices were being cut by 50 per cent. to about eight to 10 hours a week, and they were trying to juggle the hours so the sub-postmistress who managed the system could do so on different days. I was anxious at the beginning, but it has settled down. My hon. Friend the Minister has been to view the system in operation. At the public meeting last January, people were demanding that the sub-post office open on a Saturday morning. It was ironic. A woman who had run the post office with her husband some time before got up and said, ““It's a pity that no one wanted to use the sub-post office on a Saturday morning when we were running the business and shop.”” People have genuine concerns, but their genuine commitment is also important. That is why—somewhat tongue in cheek—I asked the Minister responsible during the last session of questions to the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform, ““How many of us in this Chamber will use our sub-post offices when we reach retirement age and our state pension is paid into a Post Office card account?”” We must give a commitment as individuals and communities to use those facilities. The outreach system has been relatively successful. Another recent experience—perhaps it relates to the point made by my hon. Friend the Member for Sittingbourne and Sheppey (Derek Wyatt)—came from a small village in my constituency that was probably under serious threat. Another sub-postmistress in a larger town some 7 miles away decided to employ the gentleman in the shop that held the sub-post office for that village. He does not work for the Post Office; he works for her. As a direct result, that post office is open every minute that the shop is open. If the shop is open 30 hours a week, the sub-post office is open 30 hours a week. He is employed by the sub-postmistress. For all intents and purposes, it is a franchise. In another initiative in my constituency, a group of people have come together in an attractive small village to develop a facility to re-establish their post office. It will happen on 11, 12 and 13 December. It is a major initiative being undertaken by local people. I turn to the subject of Crown post offices or directly managed services. As I said earlier, I wonder whether some of these businesses are making money. I ask because the directly managed post office in Dumfries closed about 18 months ago. It was perceived to be a very busy post office, with people constantly queuing—I mean no disrespect to the staff, who were working very hard—but a business decision was made by Post Office Ltd that it should be closed. Despite the fact that everyone saw it as being a busy post office, I was astonished when Post Office Ltd made me aware of its annual losses. I therefore say to my colleagues that being busy does not mean being profitable, because additional costs lie within. I thank you, Sir John, for allowing me to contribute to the debate and to share my thoughts. There are ways forward. I have given a commitment to my constituents, because the changes will happen next summer in my area. If the service is under threat, but people can make a commitment to use it, we should explore all the opportunities that might arise through delivering it in a different form. We are all beginning to recognise that standing still is not an option. We need to think outside the box when deciding how to provide those services in future.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
468 c160-2WH 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
Westminster Hall
Subjects
Access Cost effectiveness Closures Government assistance Public participation Post offices
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk