Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Bassam of Brighton (Labour) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 22 January 2008. It occurred during Debates on delegated legislation on Passenger and Goods Vehicles (Recording Equipment) (Downloading and Retention of Data) Regulations 2008.


Passenger and Goods Vehicles (Recording Equipment) (Downloading and Retention of Data) Regulations 2008

I am grateful to both noble Lords who have participated, particularly the noble Lord, Lord Newby, who is acting as a stand-in for the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw. He has usefully alighted on issues that I know the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw, has close to his heart. As the noble Lord, Lord Hanningfield, will remember, the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw, raised the issue of rural bus services, on which we have had some useful discourse. It is perhaps worth reminding ourselves why we have these regulations. They are intended to promote road safety; I do not think that there is anything between us on the importance of doing that. They are also intended to promote decent working conditions and fair competition. Those are all important objectives. As such, they are of particular importance to the road transportation industry and to drivers throughout Europe, as we have been reminded by some of the questions asked this afternoon. The regulations will improve the security of drivers’ hours recording and prevent abuses. It has been estimated that, in the longer term, they will save money by reducing administrative burdens associated with the current analogue system. This is relevant, because we estimate savings of around £15 million a year in 2009, rising to £24 million a year in 2010. That is no insignificant saving. The regulations complete the legislative process through which they were introduced. One can fairly argue that they more than offset other operating costs to operators, which I am sure will be welcome to smaller operators, in particular those operating bus services. In preparing the regulations, we consulted widely and took on board many of the comments received. Our final proposals on downloading default periods received strong support from the industry, the Vehicle and Operator Services Agency and the police, who have responsibility for enforcing the EU drivers’ hours and tachograph rules across Great Britain. Without the downloading requirements set out in the regulations, enforcement authorities would have difficulty obtaining key information from digital tachographs and those few unscrupulous operators would find it easier to avoid providing these data. That would have an adverse impact on road safety. It is also worth reminding ourselves that there is a need to amend existing legislative requirements on record keeping to avoid a conflict with the new EU requirements and to ensure that drivers and operators are not put in a position where they cannot comply with the law. The revised period of 42 days for drivers to return records to their employer reflects views put forward by the industry during consultation. The regulations provide for enforcement of the new requirements. They will make specific provision for proceedings against corporate and unincorporated bodies for offences under the drivers’ hours and tachograph legislation generally. The burden of record keeping will now be firmly placed on transport operators. Both noble Lords referred to rural bus services; I had the full version of the concern about that when this matter was discussed last year. Both old and new EU regulations apply to bus drivers operating on routes of more than 50 kilometres, so in that respect nothing has changed. The new EU regulation has changed some core provisions on breaks and rest periods. In addition, drivers on regular services on routes of more than 50 kilometres now need to record their hours using tachographs rather than written records, so the scope for falsification is more limited. When the new EU regulation was being negotiated, the Government received little evidence from the industry to suggest that these changes would cause any problems for bus operators, particularly rural bus operators. Our flexibility to provide dispensations for particular circumstances is very limited. I see no realistic prospect of securing the necessary level of support from other member states to change the regulation. The noble Lord, Lord Newby, asked about the meeting that I agreed to organise. Jim Fitzpatrick, my colleague, recently met representatives of rural bus operators and the Confederation of Passenger Transport to explore the issues that have been raised this afternoon and the solutions that there might be within the constraints of the new EU regulation. Following that meeting, he agreed to provide further clarity on what constitutes a route for the purposes of the 50-kilometre limit. Officials will shortly be holding discussions with the Vehicle and Operator Services Agency and the Confederation of Passenger Transport on the issue. In the end, it is for the courts to interpret the law. The Government can vary how the domestic drivers’ hours rules apply to drivers of regular services on routes not exceeding 50 kilometres, but not to the extent that the rules would conflict with or undermine the EU regulation, which takes precedence over domestic legislation. In the past, the courts have ruled that attempts to split a route artificially—for example, by changing the destination board on a vehicle part-way through a journey—do not have the effect of dividing a longer route into two shorter routes. We are not in a position to overturn that decision. That is as much information as I can provide on that issue. I understand the point that is being made on it, but I think that the companies will have to adjust. Some of the savings that they will make in the cost of operating the system will compensate them for some of the additional costs that they might have to bear in rostering and so on. Both noble Lords raised the issue of enforcement against foreign drivers. That is understandably a matter of concern. The noble Lord, Lord Hanningfield, gave some figures, which sounded familiar to me. They underline a problem of which we are very conscious. It is not surprising that foreign drivers find it more difficult to comply with UK road regulations; I am sure that UK drivers experience similar difficulties abroad. That does not mean that they should be immune from the full force of the law and proper regulation. We in this country rightly pride ourselves on our efforts to drive up driver standards. For a long time we have proudly told the world that we are one of the best and safest countries in the world in which to drive. That is certainly still the case. I think that our road safety record is the third or fourth best in Europe, which is a great credit to the way in which Governments of both faiths have endeavoured to drive up standards. All commercial vehicles and drivers are required to comply with the law, irrespective of whether their operating base is in the UK or elsewhere. VOSA targets the non-compliant using modern technology, such as automatic number-plate recognition to spot operators who have a poor track record of compliance and weigh-in-motion centres to spot overweight vehicles. I am sure that that approach is the most effective use of resources and that it minimises the risk of inconveniencing the compliant. VOSA also makes considerable efforts to share information about non-compliance across the EU, as we would obviously prefer such car drivers not to enter the UK in the first instance. Since the beginning of 2006-07, VOSA has significantly stepped up the level of enforcement activity in respect of commercial vehicles undertaking international journeys. It has also doubled the number of enforcement checks on potentially non-compliant vehicles during the past financial year and will increase the level of checks again by a further 20 per cent in the current financial year. It has committed 10 extra front-line staff around the country to extend the work of the now completed south-east international pilot for transport nationally and it has been given an extra £2 million in 2008-09 for HGV enforcement. All drivers are required to carry records for the current day and the previous 28 days to enable enforcement authorities to check compliance with EU drivers’ rules at the roadside. The regulations do not affect enforcement at the roadside. They are necessary to ensure that GB operators maintain sufficient records so that drivers’ hours checks can be undertaken by enforcement officers at operators’ premises. Enforcement against non-Great Britain HGV operators is now easier and we have endeavoured to ensure that the burdens on courts are proportionate. The Road Safety Act 2006 introduced new measures to allow foreign offenders to be issued with on-the-spot fines. Those measures will enable VOSA and the police to issue fixed penalties to both UK and foreign offenders in respect of non-endorsable and endorsable offences. Where offenders cannot show that they have a satisfactory UK/GB address, they will be required to pay a deposit on the spot, equivalent to the level of the fixed penalty. Vehicles can be immobilised by the police or VOSA. The only case in which a driver or vehicle is prohibited from continuing a journey is if it seems likely that the driver will abscond or when they have declined to pay the requested financial deposit. The penalties will be graduated so that they reflect the severity of the number of offences committed and the scheme is equivalent to the on-the-spot fines levied by the enforcement agencies in most other member states. I made reference to the south-east pilot. In recognition of concerns about the greater proportion of vehicles breaking the rules being those driven by drivers on international journeys, last year VOSA increased the level of roadside enforcement resources available in the south-east. The objective of that was to increase fivefold the number of vehicles checked at south-east ports, as compared with the previous financial year, and to double the number of vehicles on international journeys checked inland. That pilot resulted in a significant increase in the number of vehicles checked for roadworthiness and the number of prohibitions issued for non-compliance. Those prohibitions can have a fairly dramatic effect. The pilot has now been wheeled out nationwide. The noble Lord, Lord Hanningfield, asked about the application of the requirement to fit a digital tachograph. My understanding is that the requirement applies only to new vehicles put into service from 1 May 2006; I think that that is the answer that the noble Lord is after. There is no mandatory requirement for operators to retro-fit older vehicles with a digital tachograph. I have probably covered all the points raised. If I have not, Members of the Committee are free to ask again.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
698 c59-62GC 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Buses Digital technology EU law Large goods vehicles Working hours Vehicles Tachographs
Legislation
Passenger and Goods Vehicles (Recording Equipment) (Downloading and Retention of Data) Regulations 2008
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk