Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Stephen O'Brien (Conservative) in the House of Commons on Thursday, 13 March 2008. It occurred during Adjournment debate on Older People's Rights (Health Care).


Older People's Rights (Health Care)

The hon. Gentleman advocates his position even better than I can, and I am most grateful that he was able to intervene. Therefore, we all doubly share in the disappointment, because we are already now in March of the following year, and that seems to indicate that there is a serious dragging of feet. In the Westminster Hall debate on 11 December 2007, to which I referred earlier, the Minister who is present today called the current state of affairs an ““anomaly””, saying that"““neither Government nor Parliament intended that publicly funded residents living in private sector establishments would not be covered by the Human Rights Act 1998. That is an unintended consequence, and we need to put it right.””—[Official Report, Westminster Hall, 11 December 2007; Vol. 469, c. 52WH.]" During the Committee stage of the Health and Social Care Bill, the Minister of State said:"““the Government are committed to ensuring that independent sector care homes are covered by the Human Rights Act.””––[Official Report, Health and Social Care Public Bill Committee, 10 January 2008; c. 135.]" Why will the Government not deal with that matter now? If they are truly committed to dealing with it, what is the reason for the delay? I hope that I have put questions to the Minister in a fair manner, and I am sure that he will take the opportunity to give us specific answers to the issues raised both by myself and the hon. Member for Hendon, who I again congratulate on securing this debate. I also congratulate him and his colleagues in the Joint Committee on producing this report. I am sure that we will see some movement on the part of the Government, but there will still be too much prevarication and, as I see it, another attempt to find sufficient long grass to kick this issue into. I look forward to the Minister dispelling such a notion, which has obviously formed in my mind, and giving specific answers to the specific questions that I have posed. If, for any reason, he is not able to answer them today, I hope that he will be prepared to let us have some answers in writing. Let us not forget that at the heart of this debate is the care of some of the most vulnerable people in our society. That is something that all of us, and I include the Government in saying that, take seriously, as we ought to.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
473 c140WH 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
Westminster Hall
Subjects
Care homes Hospitals Health services Human rights Hospital wards Hospital beds NHS Older people Mental health services Standards Joint Committee on Human Rights
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk