Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Christopher Chope (Conservative) in the House of Commons on Friday, 25 April 2008. It occurred during Debate on bill on Food Products (Marketing to Children) Bill.


Food Products (Marketing to Children) Bill

Absolutely. The Bill has a number of shortcomings, including the absence of a proper cost-benefit analysis or regulatory impact assessment. The Bill does not even have any explanatory notes attached to it, which we would normally expect to see on Second Reading and which might be able to throw some light on the potential impact of clause 3, for instance. The situation is not that there is no scientific evidence in support of the Bill; the situation is that there is scientific evidence against it, which the hon. Member for Edinburgh, South conveniently omitted from his introduction. He started with such enthusiastic, over-the-top language that he was clearly hyped up—I do not know what he had in his diet this morning, but he was certainly not in a position to overstate his case. Let us consider some of the evidence that exists, some of which is produced in an excellent article that has been drawn to my attention by Patrick Basham and John Luik, the co-authors of ““Diet Nation: Exposing the Obesity Crusade””. They point out that"““none of the studies purporting to demonstrate that food advertising causes childhood obesity control for more than a handful of…other risk factors. These studies…cannot establish an evidence-based case about the connection between food advertising and children's weight.""If food advertising caused children's weight gain and obesity, wouldn't you expect to find an increase in advertising that parallels the increase in obesity? This is not the case. UK food and drink ad spending has been falling in real terms since 1999 and is now roughly at 1982 levels…while rates of overweight and obesity have been rising.””" The projections are that those rates will continue to rise under the Government. The authors also point out that "““in 1982 food ads constituted 34 per cent. of total television advertising, whereas in 2002 they made up only 18 per cent. Where is the link between food advertising and children's weight, let alone children's obesity?””" In the US, similar evidence has been adduced. According to the Federal Trade Commission, advertising during children's television programming has declined by 34 per cent. in recent years and food advertising on television has declined by 13 per cent. since 1993. However, there is no evidence that childhood obesity levels in the US have declined as a result. The authors then say that if the level of advertising has not increased, perhaps the level of television viewing has increased. In fact, to the surprise of many—including me—television viewing has not increased over the period of the obesity epidemic. Some observers suggest that it has not changed for children and adolescents for the past 40 years. There is some evidence that the time children spend watching television has actually declined in recent years. The idea that people are getting fatter because they are couch potatoes may be wrong according to that evidence. The authors then draw attention to the fact that when children sit down and watch television, they view a balanced presentation of foods. A British study looked at the food messages and references in regular programming, as opposed to those contained in food advertising, because there are as many references to food in regular programming as during the adverts. Children's regular programming contained references far more centred on so-called healthy foods. For example, fruit and vegetables were the most frequently portrayed foods in regular programming, and that might be regarded as positive advertising for healthy eating. If one of the unintended consequences of the Bill would be less good children's programming, there would be less opportunity for those positive messages to be put across.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
474 c1625-6 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Children Advertising Broadcasting programmes Diabetes Food Labelling Heart diseases Nutrition Marketing Mental health Obesity Sports Television
Legislation
Food Products (Marketing to Children) Bill 2007-08
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk