Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Sutherland of Houndwood (Crossbench) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 18 November 2008. It occurred during Question for short debate on Commonwealth Scholarship and Fellowship Scheme.


Commonwealth Scholarship and Fellowship Scheme

I also record gratitude to the noble Lord, Lord Luce, for providing the opportunity for me to speak on these important matters that are sometimes unconsidered. The Government occasionally, although not often, seem a little timid and do not actually take credit where it is due. They can have immense influence in this area and on the university system, but not by withdrawing funds. They can influence the climate within which all British universities operate, the climate of saying that it is important to have overseas students and to have future leaders in our midst. The Government set the climate of opinion. At the moment, they are setting it in an important direction, which puts scholarship funds towards poorer students in this country. That is quite right—but if, at the same time, they withdraw funding from overseas students, the message becomes distorted. The input of government money allows universities to spend sums that they might otherwise have to commit in ways that are wide and various in their impact. I want to crystallise and to particularise. This is a tale of three men who were scholarship students in this country—Archbishop Desmond Tutu, Archbishop Ndungane, his successor as Archbishop of Cape Town, and Barney Pityana. I declare an interest because I had the privilege of teaching the latter two. I did not teach them very much, but formally I was their teacher. They were able to come to the UK in the darkest times of apartheid in South Africa because there were people in this country who were prepared to put money into creating scholarships. If the Government had given a different message, who knows what the position might have been. Two of those people might not have been alive today. A very strong message can be sent from government. All three were overseas students who studied at King’s College London. I do not know about choosing future leaders; all three were clergymen who studied theology. I am not sure that that is topical, but there you are. All three are key figures in post-apartheid South Africa, and all three have had a massive influence in the development of that country since the creation of a presidency under Mandela and free open elections. There is no need to rehearse the great contributions which Desmond Tutu has made, but his aides told me when I once visited him of his personal bravery by standing as chancellor of the University of the Western Cape between, on the one side, discontented and protesting students in the early hours of the morning, and on the other side, the armed militia and policemen who were intent on stopping the protest. His personal courage is often not recognised in the way that it should be, because we concentrate on his wider contributions. His successor, Archbishop Ndungane again had to flee South Africa with his family and was able to study in this country because scholarships were available; the climate was right. Eventually, he was able to return to his own country to become in the late 1980s principal of a theological college, Bishop of the Orange Free State—not a sinecure by any means in the late 1980s and early 1990s—and, finally, he was Desmond Tutu’s successor. Archbishop Ndungane, when he more recently visited this country, was asked by a student, ““You were on Devil’s Island. Did you see Mandela’s tomb?””. He answered, ““I think I built it””. That was the position he was in; he had to get out, he came here with his family and the rest is good news. Barney Pityana is perhaps less well known. Desmond Tutu was asked to take on the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. Barney also had to flee with his family. We used to get strange guttural South African voices asking for his address in London. ““We are friends of Barney””, they would say; we took that with a pinch of whatever. Barney was talent-spotted by the then very enlightened vice-chancellor of Cape Town University, and was taken back to South Africa, where he became an assistant principal. Then he was in a position to chair the Human Rights Commission there, which was thought to be a poisoned chalice. But he carried it out in a way that I suppose his great mentor, Desmond Tutu, did, creating reconciliation, a sense of what was true and an attachment to human rights. Bringing these people here is not simply an enhancement of the experience of UK students, although it is that. It is not simply a means of advertising the qualities of UK higher education, although it is that. And it is not simply a way of enhancing UK direct influence, which we have heard much about. It is a way in which, albeit indirectly, this country made a contribution to the future of South Africa. These three went back and held key appointments at a time when it could all have gone wrong. They have helped create a country which will have a huge influence in that troubled continent, a country based on truth, reconciliation, decency, human rights and democracy. The climate of opinion that brings folks like that here is in part the background to the very specific question that has been raised by my noble friend Lord Luce.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
705 c111-2GC 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Commonwealth Finance Overseas students Universities Research Foreign and Commonwealth Office Postgraduate education Scholarships Chevening scholarships programme Marshall scholarships Commonwealth scholarships programme
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk