Proceeding contribution from Lord Redwood (Conservative) in the House of Commons on Tuesday, 3 March 2009. It occurred during Debate on bill on Corporation Tax Bill.
Corporation Tax Bill
That may show that they have good tax advisers and are happy to stay here on that basis, or it may show that they are simply not profitable enough because of the general background. I understand why, unfortunately, a lot of companies will not be paying tax in future; it is because of the desperate conditions in which they find themselves. We all want fair taxation at a fair level. If I were asked whether the complexity was more or less important than the rate, I would say that the rate is the most important thing. However, complexity is an issue, and complexity allied to too many changes or to too vicarious a system can be extremely worrying. A feeling has built up in some parts of the corporate sector. People are not sure what the law is. Furthermore, there can be changes, through the anti-avoidance and anti-evasion measures strengthened and taken by the Government—sometimes for good reasons—and through judicial or Revenue decisions that try to interpret the rather complex law. That combination of a rate that is no longer that competitive with the legal complexity and too many changes that people cannot understand or do not think were properly heralded, can create uncertainty and lead to companies leaving these shores. My worry is that length and complexity go together. It is reassuring to hear the architects tell us that many people want the issues spelt out in detail and that that has now happened in lucid and clear prose so that people can relax and know exactly where they are. I confess that, probably in common with most speakers in this debate, I have read some but not all the Bill. Anyone trying to read it would rapidly come to the conclusion that it is difficult for anybody but an accountant specialising in corporation tax to understand what it means for any given business. Let us look at clauses 190 and 191 on page 85. Clause 190 tries to give a basic meaning of "post-cessation receipt". It says that it means""a sum…which is received after a person permanently ceases to carry on a trade, and…which arises from the carrying on of the trade before the cessation."" I can understand that. However, the clause goes on to say:""In this Chapter, except in sections 194 and 195, references to a person permanently ceasing to carry on a trade include—""(a) in the case of a company, the occurrence of an event treated under section 18 of ITTOIA 2005 (companies beginning or ceasing to be within charge to income tax) as the company permanently ceasing to carry on the trade, and""(b) in the case of a trade carried on by a person in partnership, the occurrence of an event treated under section 246(4) of ITTOIA 2005 (basic meaning of "post-cessation receipt") as the person permanently ceasing to carry on the trade."" I shall spare the House clause 191, but it is another little gem, citing another series of sections of legislation to which the relevant people have to cross-refer. That little sample of the delights of this reading for insomniacs tells us that the Bill is certainly not a clear and lucid exposé that an intelligent, rational man or woman could read and immediately understand; they would still need to rush to their advisers to try to get to grips with it. The Bill gets more exciting in parts; I did not quote one of the most exciting bits. Clause 479, for example, invites us to learn about""non-lending relationships not involving discounts"." The mind boggles at what might be involved in one of those non-lending relationships, but, helpfully, we are told that""A company has a relevant non-lending relationship if—""(a) the company stands, or has stood, in the position of a creditor or debtor in relation to a money debt,""(b) the money debt did not arise from a transaction for the lending of money…and""(c) the money debt is one of the kinds mentioned in subsection (2)."" We then go through five other subsections to clause 479 to try to wrestle with the complicated issue of what a non-lending relationship not involving a discount is. Having passed the GCSE, we can then go on to the scholarship—relevant non-lending relationships involving a discount. These are just samples to show that this law is getting exceedingly complicated. One of the clauses that I most like, because it has a topical flavour to it, is clause 524—"Shares subject to outstanding third party obligations". I wonder if when that was written people had in mind our growing shareholdings in the British banking system. It says:""This section applies to the share held by the investing company if it…is subject to outstanding third party obligations (see subsection (2)), and…is an interest-like investment…For the purposes of this Chapter a share is subject to outstanding third party obligations if…the share is subject to obligations of a kind specified in subsection (4)…the obligations are…obligations of a person other than the investing company, or…obligations of the investing company which, under any relevant arrangements, will or might be discharged directly or indirectly by any other person, and…the obligations are yet to be discharged…Accordingly, those obligations are the 'third party obligations' in the case of that share…The kinds of obligation"—" ones with which we are getting very familiar under this Government—""are…an obligation to meet unpaid calls on the share"—" there will be plenty of those—""and any other obligation to make a contribution to the capital of the issuing company that could affect the value of the share."" That is all too poignant and topical. Obviously, people had great foresight in putting in those provisions to deal with the burgeoning volume of cash that we, for no good reason, are tipping into banks that need to sort out their costs and lending policies rather more quickly. I should like the Minister to respond to these points of principle about whether we need to continue with this kind of process in future. Perhaps my hon. Friend the Member for Gosport, who has worked valiantly, should be given a different remit on a future piece of legislation, whereby we would see that there is some connection between length and complexity and that the length of a Bill is not necessarily an indication that it is easier to understand or more likely to avoid all kinds of dispute. Lawyers are very clever people. Private sector lawyers tend to get paid rather more than parliamentary draftsmen and public sector lawyers trying to battle against them in terms of such legislation. Far from reducing the number of uncertainties, the longer the Bill, the more causes for action there will be. The more words there are in a Bill, the more it can be challenged in court and the fewer the people who know the true tax base of the country. We are in danger of not being able to see the wood for the huge number of trees that have been felled to produce the paper for this legislation. I cannot believe that 821 pages of law to do about the half the job on corporation tax represents the final statement on simplification. I live in some fear that once people have homed in and boned up on this legislation, some 22 days later the Chancellor may wish to make fairly big changes to it. Of course, I understand that it is a founding text for a period of years, but if Chancellors decide to make too many changes to founding texts, that has the added hazard of all the amendments and complications added on top of the 821 pages of law. Surely there is a better way. This will not be welcomed by the business community currently resident in Britain, and I fear that this is not the answer to those who are leaving this country saying the law is too complex.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 488 c772-4
- Session
- 2008-09
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Commons chamber
- Subjects
- Accountancy Companies Corporation tax Bureaucracy Income Small businesses Taxation
- Legislation
- Corporation Tax Bill 2008-09
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2024-04-21 10:07:46 +0100
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_533936
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_533936
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_533936