Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Bates (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Monday, 8 June 2009. It occurred during Debate on bill on Business Rate Supplements Bill.


Business Rate Supplements Bill

My Lords, I support the amendment in two particular regards, and I seek some clarification. The points that have been made have been perfectly presented by my noble friends Lord Jenkin of Roding and Lord Brooke of Sutton Mandeville, and I have two points to add. I draw on similar experiences under the previous Conservative Government, in which I had the joy of occupying the position of Paymaster General in looking after such matters, albeit temporarily in the final days of that Administration. To a degree, I can buy the careful wording used in this letter on the point of not wanting to bind or have the issue of precedent before us. However, the final sentence of the fourth paragraph states: ""Therefore whilst I am advised that it is impossible to give a definitive answer in general terms rather than on a case by case basis, it remains unlikely that a voluntary contribution would be tax deductible"." In many ways, that is the issue. I could understand if the sentence finished at "on a case by case basis". One could accept that as a reasonable response from the Treasury. However, to add, ""it remains unlikely that a voluntary contribution would be tax deductible"" seems to bind the hands in a way it sought to avoid. Once the City of London comes to realise, particularly those businesses which have offered a total of £150 million, that this sum will not be tax deductible, the consequence will be that it acts as a huge disincentive for future schemes that may be offered elsewhere in the country and for those who may still be considering a voluntary contribution to Crossrail. The issue needs to be dealt with. We are familiar with this kind of test in standard wording such as "wholly and exclusively in pursuit of the interests of the business". If the contribution was not wholly in the interests of the business, why on earth would it be made in the first place? It is bizarre to argue that a business might give 100 per cent for the sake of getting relief on 20 per cent. That is a non sequitur. Of course such contributions are made wholly in pursuit of the interests of business; that is why organisations make such investments. It is also the reason why this letter, albeit that it has been guided by the hand of the Treasury, is entirely wrong to suggest that such matters should be judged on a case by case basis. In the case of contributions made to Crossrail, the answer should most certainly be that they are tax deductible because they are expenses incurred wholly in pursuit of the interests of the business.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
711 c502-3 
Session
2008-09
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Companies Costs Business Elizabeth line Finance Liability Donors Greater London Infrastructure Empty property Local government Local government finance Public transport Rates and rating Property Business rates Wales Tax allowances Valuation Taxation Business improvement districts Community infrastructure levy
Legislation
Business Rate Supplements Bill 2008-09
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk