Proceeding contribution from Paul Robert Holmes (Liberal Democrat) in the House of Commons on Thursday, 11 June 2009. It occurred during Adjournment debate on Policing in the 21st Century.
Policing in the 21st Century
I apologise, Mr. Williams, but the matter is directly relevant to the aspect of the Select Committee report that we are discussing and the question of how to get necessary accountability. The Liberal Democrats would want proportional representation for police boards, as for every election, but the question is what sort of proportional representation to use. Opponents always choose the worst example they can think of, such as the Israeli list system or the closed list system for the European Parliament. That is not the method that any sensible person who wants PR would suggest. The single transferable vote that was adopted a few years ago with massive success by New Zealand, which has an English-style democratic system, is exactly what we would propose, not the bad systems that people hold up as an example. The question of directly elected boards and how to hold the police to account leads on to the section of the Select Committee report about resources and how to finance the police. At the moment, as the report clearly and succinctly explains, most funding for the police, like most instruction for the police, comes from London. We are one of the most centralised countries in the western world. Some 90 per cent. of taxation is raised by No. 11 Downing street. It goes, effectively, to No. 11 Downing street, and is handed out with strings attached. No other western country works in that way. Other countries raise money locally and spend it locally on police, education, health and other things, and need not ask the capital city for permission to do so. We are the exception, as with PR. The Liberal Democrats argue that the resources issue should be dealt with differently, and that is why we want locally elected police boards. We do not want them just so they can do what police authorities do now. We are thinking about much more powerful local police authorities with power over the raising of finance. The Select Committee report sets out clearly why such reform is needed. At the moment, although there is variation across the country—I think that the figure is as low as 50 per cent. in Surrey—most police forces, like most local authorities, get anything up to 70 or 75 per cent. of their funding as grant from central Government. Only 20 to 30 per cent. comes from the local council tax precept that the police authority sets. That has led to some immense problems for police forces. I mentioned Surrey, and there was a debate two days ago in Westminster Hall on the Surrey capping issue, during which I managed to make some contributions with reference to the Derbyshire comparison that has already been raised. The Government hand out most of the money, give most of the directives to the police about what they must do, and set most of the targets that they must meet, but they use a formula that they admitted in 2006 was inadequate and unfair, leading them to introduce a new formula based on need. They then said that they could not introduce the new formula, and thus told Derbyshire, "You need £5 million more a year if you are to deliver the policing that we, the Government, say you should, but you cannot have it." As the Committee's report points out, some authorities have been even worse hit. It points out that the West Midlands force received nearly 11 per cent.—£48 million—less than the funding formula would have given it in 2007-08, if that formula had been applied. The Government said, "You need all this money, but you cannot have it." Yet another force, Northumbria, gets 12 per cent. more than it should, according to the central Government funding formula. The system of ceilings and floors—to ensure that change takes place relatively slowly and that all an authority's surplus money is not taken away immediately to be given to an underfunded one—is understandable if there is a sensible and logical time scale in which the funding schemes are brought together so that everyone is funded equitably. However, that is not happening. It is happening for fire authorities and, to some extent, for local authorities, but not for police authorities. Quite a number of authorities, including Derbyshire, have been told, "You are badly underfunded and need more money than you get to do your job. When we send inspectors to assess your police force, we will assess you against forces that are being paid more money than they need to do the job, and we will criticise you because you are not doing your job properly, even though you are underfunded. Who is underfunding you? We are—central Government. What can you do about it? Nothing." That is because if an authority tries, as Derbyshire has done this year with support from MPs and councillors of all three parties, and as Surrey has done, to raise the money from the council tax precept, the Government caps it. Derbyshire is not being forced to rebill this year, which would waste large amounts of money to save slightly larger amounts, but it is being informed that it will lose the relevant amount of money next year, so it is being told, "We are not going to take the money off you this year; we'll take it off you next year." Derbyshire must lose £1.6 million, but that amounts to 60 front-line police officers losing their jobs to meet the Government's council tax capping directive. I am not the one who says so; it is Mick Creedon, the chief constable of Derbyshire. Surrey is in an even worse position and other authorities, such as Leicestershire and Lincolnshire, went through the process last year. It is a problem across the board. The rationale that the Government gave in the debate two days ago for what they were doing was a very confused one—they said that Derbyshire, for example, was setting an excessive budget. The extra money on the council tax would have raised about £1.6 million, but the Government have said that Derbyshire police are £5 million underfunded. How can raising an extra £1.6 million towards a £5 million underfunding be an excessive budget? It still does not reach the spending level that the Government say is needed. It is ludicrous and illogical—and completely undemocratic. Derbyshire and Surrey police authorities, and others last year, consulted their council tax payers and all the different councils and elected bodies at different levels, as well as getting MPs from different parties on board; and central Government said, "You cannot do this." There is an utter dislocation between local police forces and the Government, who told them that there must be localism, that they must be accountable to local people and that they must do what local people want. People in Derbyshire want police on the beat. They do not understand why Derbyshire has 380 fewer people in uniform on the streets than an equivalent shire county, or why some have more people on the beat because they have been given the money that should have gone to Derbyshire. However, Derbyshire cannot do anything about that. It cannot raise the money through local taxation, even if local people are willing for that to happen, because the Government say no. There cannot be localism and police forces cannot be accountable to the local area if that is not allowed to happen. That is why we must change completely the resourcing of police forces. There must be local accountability. That is why we argue that police authorities cannot continue to be, in effect, appointed quangos, albeit that some of their members have been elected to other authorities. There must be properly elected police boards to deliver the finance and local accountability that the Government say is needed, but prevent from happening, and towards which the Select Committee report shows we should move in admirable detail and clarity. The immigration and foreign workers section of the Select Committee report was interesting, if only for one sentence. The evidence shows that the policing issue related to immigrant workers and communities—contrary to public or media opinion—is that""foreign nationals are more likely to be victims than perpetrators of crime."" In areas such as Chesterfield, where significant groups of eastern European workers have arrived in recent years, the cost of providing interpreters is a great burden on police forces, especially given the range of languages that are spoken. However, they are more likely to be interpreting for a victim of crime than for somebody who has been charged with committing a crime. Government funding for interpreters is too slow and ineffective to meet the problem. It is based on the 10-yearly censuses, so it does not take account of quick population movements. Only two years ago, a large number of eastern European workers came to this country. Many of them are now leaving because of the recession, or because they have earned the money they wanted to raise and are going back to set up businesses in their home countries. We benefit from their work and the economy in places such as Poland will benefit in return, which is what the European Union is all about. The Government funding formula does not respond to the problem of the cost of interpreters quickly enough. We see the same problem in education, housing and elsewhere. It was worth pointing out just that one sentence of the Select Committee report to show that foreign nationals are more likely to be the victims of crime than the cause of it. However, the problem of the cost of interpreters must be dealt with. Alcohol has been dealt with today by the Chairman of the Select Committee, and it has been discussed at length during the passage of the Policing and Crime Bill and in other debates. There is a missed opportunity. The 24-hour café culture that the Licensing Act 2003 envisaged has not come about. Instead, we have more drinking in town centres and it is more spread out. The police used to need extra numbers on duty from 11 o'clock at night to 2 o'clock in the morning on Thursdays, Fridays and Saturdays. That police presence must now be spread out right through to 6 o'clock in the morning. That is the experience in Chesterfield, and it causes more difficulties for policing and makes it more expensive. According to my local police and the evidence given to the Policing and Crime Bill Committee, the main problem is not town centre drinking venues and the results of the Licensing Act 2003, but under-age drinking. The problem is cheap booze in off-licences and off-premises, with cheap super-strength lagers and ciders being sold at rock-bottom prices as loss-leaders to get people into supermarkets. Regrettably, the Government sidestepped that problem in the Policing and Crime Bill. There is much talk of strengthening powers to control licensees and pubs, but in that proposal, too, there is far too much direction from London, instead of local authorities being able to decide where the problems are. Local authorities know their areas far better than anybody sitting here in London. All the emphasis has been on that issue and there has been nothing about stopping super-strength, cheap booze getting into the hands of under-age drinkers on the streets so easily. Whenever I am on patrol with the police, police community support officers and special constables in Chesterfield, I ask what is the biggest source of problems. They always say that it is the early-evening nuisance around the high streets, shopping centres and play areas where kids congregate with cheap, super-strength booze that they have bought from off premises. It is much harder to control that problem than town centre pubs, because it is scattered across the community. The Government seem to be closing their eyes to that problem, as the eloquent testimony of the Chairman of the Select Committee showed. I agree with the Select Committee recommendations on alcohol disorder zones and the "polluter pays" principle, under which the pubs and all-night drinking establishments that cause these problems should help to pay to solve them. I also agree with minimum pricing and the control of loss-leading sales of cheap alcohol. Unfortunately, the Government seem to be avoiding tackling these issues. What I said in my opening comments is also true of knife crime. Although crime has been falling, nobody believes the statistics. Many people have a fear of crime, but they do not read the statistics. The statistics on knife crime, if they can be believed, show that it has slowly decreased over the past seven years. However, especially after last year's feast of press coverage on some of the tragic murders, everybody believes that knife crime has soared through the roof. In truth, the press suddenly paid major attention to these tragic deaths, having not done so for the previous six years. There was a debate about knife crime in the main Chamber on Tuesday, which was repeated in part in yesterday's debate on youth crime in this Chamber, and in which I participated. Nobody disputes the seriousness of the issues and the need to deal with knife crime, but the interesting statistics in the report suggest that knife crime is in slow decline rather than soaring through the roof. There has been much discussion of how we should deal with knife crime in the debates of the past two days. Intelligence-led policing is one method, and there are good examples of that in the past 18 months in London. Targeted stop-and-search powers have been used in problem areas, and mobile arch metal detectors have been used. On a recent Select Committee visit to New York, we saw those arches in use at the entrance of every school that we visited. We are a long way from having to go down that road, but the use of mobile arches and intelligent stop-and-search powers have a big role to play, as long as we never go back to the heavy-handed days of the sus laws, which caused such problems in the 1970s. One example of intelligence-led policing that has been mentioned in recent debates comes from Cardiff, where the accident and emergency unit logged anonymous reports of exactly where stabbing incidents occurred. Such schemes can cause many problems, as the medical profession does not want to report all stabbing and gunshot incidents to the police because of issues such as patient confidentiality. However, in Cardiff, incidents were reported anonymously. The police used the information not to pursue individuals, but to create a crime map and identify where the stabbings were taking place. They then diverted resources into the problem areas. In Cardiff, there was a 40 per cent. reduction in knife crime and stabbings simply through sensible, intelligence-led policing. The use of computers to analyse hot spots on a week-by-week basis has worked well in other areas of policing. Regrettably, although the Government have looked at that experiment and have introduced some pilots—we have heard that they have more pilots than the Air Force—it has not been rolled out. It is such an obvious and simple technique and has been proven to work. It means that less police time is wasted, because efforts can be targeted in the most effective way. Why are successful examples, such as the one in Cardiff, not being adopted more widely?
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 493 c314-8WH
- Session
- 2008-09
- Chamber / Committee
- Westminster Hall
- Subjects
- Accountability Crime prevention Crime Neighbourhood policing Finance Immigration Police Police community support officers Terrorism
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2023-12-05 22:02:59 +0000
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_565905
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_565905
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_565905