Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Baroness Miller of Chilthorne Domer (Liberal Democrat) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 25 June 2009. It occurred during Ministerial statement on National Security Strategy.


National Security Strategy

My Lords, we on these Benches, too, find the process by which this Statement has been made extremely regrettable. The Minister will remember that, on the Second Reading of the Policing and Crime Bill, I raised at some length the issue of cybercrime, because we felt that it was a very much more serious issue than those dealt with in some of the unnecessary parts of the Bill. It is particularly surprising and regrettable that, if the Minister had in mind the fact that there would be this big revelation on cybercrime, we could not have considered something in this House in a more structured way. This Statement is a lot more about headlines, because there is actually not much action in it. I shall give the Minister a few examples of the action that we would have been pleased to see. However, perhaps he can first tell me whether we have ratified the European Convention on Cybercrime. Particularly important is Article 25, which enables us to co-operate properly, have mutual legal assistance, respond to requests for help from other countries and make the best use of all the international provisions. This is because a lot of e-crime is perpetrated in countries such as Brazil, China and so on. Without a proper co-ordinated international effort, we will not get very far. Perhaps the Minister could also confirm that, where serious e-crime is perpetrated in third countries, the extradition arrangements are satisfactory, because the tariffs have been so low for these offences that they were not extraditable. The Minister talked of the ordinary citizen. Another enormous problem for the ordinary citizen on whom e-crime impacts heavily is that, according to a Written Answer that the Minister was kind enough to send me earlier this year, the Government do not collect central figures on e-crime in any case, so we do not know its scale. It would be interesting to know from the Minister whether the liability of banks for losses suffered by people as a result of e-crime when the banks’ security systems are not efficient is underpinned by legislation, because that area remains dependent on just the Banking Code. Will the Government look at strengthening that? The public need a lot more help in getting safe online. Will the Government, as a result of this new effort on cybercrime, launch a much more targeted and satisfactory effort on helping the public to get safe online? They should start by running an advertising campaign, obliging retailers to offer a "get safe online" package every time they sell a new computer and encouraging colleges to offer short courses on exactly what is necessary. There is an awful lot to be done in this area. Most people who are fairly computer literate are still astonishingly illiterate when it comes to how to get safe online. I admit that it is quite difficult to know all the things that you should be doing. In the parliamentary system, we are somewhat helped by having it done for us, but that cannot be said for the ordinary citizen and that needs to be addressed. The Minister spoke of an ethics advisory committee, which may offer some reassurance when we look at the centre that is to sit alongside GCHQ. However, a more practical step was suggested in this House last Friday, which was that there should be a Joint Committee, as recommended by the Constitution Committee of this House. However, the Government said in their response that they had no intention of pursuing that idea. That is a big gap. There is a lack of parliamentary oversight of this area. It is falling in a gap between the Home Office and other departments, so a Joint Committee—a considered suggestion from the Constitution Committee—would be a very good first step. If we are going to have a cybersecurity operations centre, doing all the data mining and interception of web traffic that that involves, we surely need proper parliamentary scrutiny, starting with the Joint Committee. Finally, will the Minister tell me whether he still feels, in the light of the new cybersecurity operations centre, whether RIPA is fit for purpose? I hope that we have the opportunity to debate this at greater length, because there are an awful lot of questions that we need to ask about it.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
711 c1710-1 
Session
2008-09
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Cybercrime Ethics Internet National security Organised crime Terrorism Electronic warfare Cyber Security Operations Centre Office of Cyber Security Cybersecurity
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk