Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Cheryl Gillan (Conservative) in the House of Commons on Wednesday, 14 October 2009. It occurred during Debates on delegated legislation on National Assembly for Wales (Legislative Competence) (Welsh Language).


National Assembly for Wales (Legislative Competence) (Welsh Language)

Mr. Jones, may I welcome you to the Chair? I neglected to do so at the beginning of the Committee. I notice that you are presiding over us for this morning only. May I apologise to the Secretary of State and, particularly, the Chairman of the Select Committee? I am afraid that parliamentary duties will prevent me from attending the Committee this afternoon for the winding-up speeches and I thought I should give you notice of that. I offer my congratulations to the Chairman and all the members of the Welsh Affairs Committee. It is no secret that under the auspices of the Secretary of State’s predecessor, to whom I pay a warm tribute, in our conversations—and indeed in conversation with the Secretary of State—there was considerable concern in this place about the legislative competence order and the way that it was initially presented. That is reflected in the powerful body of work carried out by the Select Committee and in its recommendations. The Secretary of State will be pleased to know that I agree that it is very important for all 40 Welsh MPs to have an opportunity to reflect on that work. However, I also agree more widely that, as is the case with this LCO process, which he set up and that he knows I think imperfect, it is important that Parliament is consulted on such matters, because we are transferring constitutional powers from one body to another. Therefore, it is right that there are views not only from Welsh MPs, but from other MPs as well, because Wales is not an island. It is linked to England and the rest of the UK. It is thus quite right and proper that there should be a say on these matters and a say from the House, otherwise we would be in dereliction of our duties. I have shared my concerns about the LCO and many of them were reflected in the body of work carried out by the Select Committee. In fact, my problem with the process we have embarked on is not that we are meeting here today, or that I have a problem with the order; it is that I cannot yet have a problem with the order, because I have not seen what it will be. The suggestion I made at the beginning of the sitting was perfectly reasonable because, without any delaying tactic at all, I thought that the Committee should have the opportunity to reflect on the order and, possibly, the Measure. It is interesting that the document from Alun Ffred Jones, the Minister for Heritage, on 6 October—only recently—stated: ““In tandem with our ongoing work on the Welsh language we have been preparing for the Welsh language Measure, which was announced in the First Minister’s legislative statement on 14 July. The Welsh Assembly Government looks forward to publishing the Welsh language Measure as soon as the National Assembly has the necessary competence to legislate on the Welsh language.”” If that work has been going on, I see no reason why the Welsh Assembly Government should not be asked to produce the draft Measure for us to look at, because it would give us an opportunity to go behind some of the intentions in the new order when it comes along. I make that suggestion merely to inform the House better, because it is important, as was stated in paragraph 110 of the Select Committee report: ““We are of the view that powers relating to the Welsh language should be transferred to the Assembly, but only on the basis of legislative precision.”” Taking those points together, I merely make a suggestion for the Secretary of State to consider and pass on to the Minister in the Welsh Assembly. If there is a Measure alongside the order when it is eventually published, it will make the process of scrutiny more easily understandable and less confrontational. That has been made obvious by the passage of this LCO and by the accusations in the press so rightly referred to by the hon. Member for Aberavon.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
WGC c24-5 
Session
2008-09
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons Grand Committees
Subjects
Legislative competence National Assembly for Wales Wales Welsh language Welsh Affairs Committee
Legislation
National Assembly for Wales (Legislative Competence) (Welsh Language) Order 2010
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk