Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Baroness Turner of Camden (Labour) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 3 November 2009. It occurred during Debate on bill on Welfare Reform Bill.


Welfare Reform Bill

I shall speak also to my Amendment 7, which is grouped with this one, as it is on a similar topic. Noble Lords will know that I have endeavoured, throughout the discussion on the Bill, to secure a change in the title of council tax benefit. The reason for that was a suggestion made to me by the British Legion, which has undertaken much research among veterans, many of whom are entitled to council tax benefit but do not claim it. The research indicated that more would claim it if it were renamed "council tax rebate". It is a matter of dignity, the British Legion believes; many are too proud to claim a benefit even though they may need it. On Report, a government amendment set out arrangements for the renaming of the benefit. This was accepted by the House at the time, but the provision said that the Secretary of State, ""may by order provide for the benefit"," to be renamed, and so on. It seemed to me that "may" was rather indefinite. In my amendment, I suggest that it should be changed to "shall". I hope that my noble friend will feel that it is a positive amendment that would be acceptable to him. As for the rest of the situation, and my Amendment 7, one problem with what the Government proposed was that there was no timeframe and no indication of how long it would take before the renaming. That was a matter of some concern to the RBL, which has been briefing me over this period. I have set out an alternative suggestion in Amendment 7, in which the Houses of Parliament should discuss and come to a decision within three months of this Act coming into force. In other words, there would be a renaming, but we would not have to wait forever for it, since it would happen within three months of the passage of the Act. That is important from the standpoint of those interested in this amendment, because we are talking about people who are not very young. Many of them have been around for a very long time and are getting older all the time—and old people do not have long to wait. Therefore, it seems reasonable to set a timeframe for renaming this benefit. When we discussed this matter at Report, the Minister was kind enough to say that he would bring back further amendments on this issue, although not on the timing. He has done so in Amendments 4, 5 and 6, which we shall shortly have the opportunity to discuss. I am very much in favour of those amendments and, when we come to discuss them, I can say that again. However, I think that the timeframe is important, and I should like some indication from the Minister whether, if the three months that I propose is not acceptable, some kind of timeframe can be indicated as to when and how long people will have to wait before the reform that they seek becomes available to them. I beg to move.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
714 c158-9 
Session
2008-09
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Council tax benefits Children Disability living allowance Disclosure of information Criminal proceedings Benefits rules Community care Employment Jobseeker's allowance Driving Disqualification Domestic abuse Drugs Fathers Medical treatments Pilot schemes Parents Misuse Passports Lone parents Parental responsibility Social security Social security benefits Rehabilitation Registration Registration of births, deaths, marriages and civil partnerships Travel restrictions Information sharing
Legislation
Welfare Reform Bill 2008-09
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk