Proceeding contribution from Baroness Greengross (Crossbench) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 26 November 2009. It occurred during Queen's speech debate on Queen’s Speech.
Queen’s Speech
My Lords, I feel sure that noble Lords from all sides of the House will agree with me that the maiden speech just delivered by the noble Lord, Lord Sacks, was deeply moving, filled with wise and cogent comment and tinged with quiet but perceptive humour. This is not really surprising, given the brilliance of his academic career both religious and secular and his willingness to enter into meaningful dialogue with people of all faiths and none, together with his clearly demonstrated belief in the value of education. It is through education that people can celebrate their diversity of culture of background as well as gaining a deeper understanding of each other. That, more than anything else, could probably lead us to a more peaceful and just world—which, I hope the noble Lord, the Chief Rabbi, will allow me to say, heaven alone knows we need. He is a great ambassador not just for the Jewish community but for our wider society and the values that we all hold so dear, as his many broadcasts and articles regularly demonstrate. I look forward, as I am sure we all do, to his participation in the business of this House with much pleasure and anticipation. I turn to today’s debate on the humble Address. I declare an interest as a commissioner on the Equality and Human Rights Commission. I will confine my remarks to those relating to the Equality Bill, health and care. Equality in this sense is not about sameness but about the ability of everyone to achieve their potential and to flourish. To that extent, the Bill is well framed and proportionate. It will help to unblock some of the systemic problems that may get in the way of equal opportunities for everyone in Britain. It should improve public service delivery and business performance; we can ill afford to underutilise or neglect the skills and talents of all our people. It extends protection to the wide range of groups that unfortunately still face discrimination today. The unfairest inequality, perhaps, that any of us may face is that of access to healthcare. Unfortunately, in 2009 health inequality remains a major problem facing us in the United Kingdom. The Health Select Committee in another place conducted its own inquiry into this issue, and in March this year published its third report into health inequalities. It found that the health of people in England has improved markedly over the past 150 years, as we know, but, despite these huge improvements, there are marked differences in the health of different groups. Perhaps the most dramatic difference is what amounts to a death sentence: if you live in the better parts of west London, you will have 10 years or more longer to live than if you happen to be born in the poorer districts of Glasgow. This is actually grotesque, and we cannot continue to tolerate it. The difference in life expectancy is between 87.8 years and 77.1 years, and that cannot continue. Health inequalities are apparent not only between people of different socio-economic groups but between men and women, between different ethnic groups and particularly among older people with mental health problems or with learning disabilities. This is not surprising in the case of older people, given the discrimination that they still often face. Drug trials, for example, are often carried out on younger people and the drugs are then prescribed to older people without full knowledge of the difference in how they will affect them. Treatment is still often denied to older people. People with dementia are often not diagnosed. In June this year Professor Sir Michael Marmot published an interim review of health inequalities in the United Kingdom. The review will contribute to the development of a cross-government national health inequalities strategy, which is desperately needed. A key issue, though, is who will pay for this and who will provide it. Methods of both accessing care and providing it are changing, as are consumer attitudes, expectations and demands. I hope that the Minister can give us an assurance that these problems will be addressed quickly. One area where there are particular issues of inequality and discrimination is in dementia, in terms of access, diagnosis, treatment and care. We know now that one in three people reaching the age of 65 will die with dementia, and numbers are rising all the time. In response, in February this year the Government published the National Dementia Strategy in England, which was a welcome sign of hope, setting out a road map for improvements in dementia services. It is essential that the strategy is translated into practice as a matter of urgency, and I hope that we can be reassured on this point. The numbers here are significant. In February 2007 the Alzheimer’s Society, in conjunction with King’s College London and the London School of Economics, published a major study on the social and economic impact of dementia in the United Kingdom. The report showed that as the UK’s population ages, the number of people with dementia will grow substantially. It also showed that there will be more than 1 million people with dementia by 2025, and the financial cost of this disease to the UK is more than £17 billion a year. We must urgently develop safe and effective treatments for people with dementia. Unless researchers develop new treatments, within a generation 1.4 million people will live with dementia in the UK alone. The summit recently convened by the Government and the Medical Research Council, which I was privileged to chair, pointed to the urgency of putting in place a co-ordinated research strategy that needs to be implemented immediately, and which will ensure that nationally and internationally co-ordinated registers are kept. The expenditure on dementia is £11 per person, while on cancer it is now £300 per person in this country. Cancer research altogether counts for £248.5 million—for dementia, the figure is £32.4 million. The difference is extraordinary when you consider that more people suffer from dementia than from cancer. Research into dementia must be greatly increased, with appropriate funding commensurate with the huge numbers of people who experience some form of this disease, and it must be introduced rapidly. Professor Martin Prince at the Institute of Psychiatry at King’s College said last September that by next year there will be 35 million people globally with dementia. By 2030 that figure will double to 65.7 million, and will be more than 115 million by 2050. In April of last year, the All-Party Group on Dementia published a report, Always a Last Resort, which revealed that up to 105,000 people with dementia are given antipsychotic drugs inappropriately. Thankfully, a tough new action plan to tackle the overprescribing of antipsychotic drugs was announced on 12 November by the Care Services Minister. Phil Hope. The action plan responds to an independent review by Professor Banerjee, commissioned by the Department of Health, and calls for the introduction of protocols for the prescribing, monitoring and reviewing of antipsychotic medication for people with dementia. That must be implemented immediately, and I hope that the Minister will be able to assure me on that point. More recently, on 17 November, the Alzheimer’s Society report Counting the Cost: Caring for People with Dementia on Hospital Wards, which was based on a survey of 2,427 people with dementia and their carers, nursing staff and nurse managers, found that 47 per cent of carers said that being in hospital had a significant negative effect on the health of the person with dementia. Meanwhile, 89 per cent of nurses said that people with dementia were treated with dignity and respect, but 36 per cent of carers said that they were not. We know that more than half of the people who have dementia and go into hospital with a broken or fractured hip stay for two weeks or more, and that people who do not have dementia come out in far less time. That has a huge cost to the nation, and if it was replicated across the whole country the costs would be extraordinary. In June this year, I chaired a dementia round table here in the Lords which revealed that while much of the basic work has been done, none of the existing strategies or recommendations was dementia-specific or covered the broad range of care, cure, cause and prevention—specifically, in looking at research. The overuse of antipsychotic drugs is a particularly insidious form of inequality and an infringement of human rights. Then in October, the Nuffield Council on Bioethics published a report on the ethical issues around dementia. It felt that the concept of "supportive care" is particularly helpful in dementia, by emphasising the need to support both the person with dementia and their family from the moment of diagnosis onwards. That would have a hugely beneficial effect, and I hope again that it will be introduced speedily. Lastly, on care, people with dementia are deemed to be in need of social care when they are in fact suffering from a terminal illness. This form of discrimination differentiates them from most other very sick people, who can benefit from NHS care that is free at the point of delivery. It leads to the current complex and incomprehensible system which people have to navigate, and through which they often pay out huge sums of money at a crisis point in their lives when they are at their most vulnerable. I look forward to the forthcoming Green Paper; that must lead quickly to a White Paper and legislation representing political consensus on a long-term agreed policy, which will be fair to dementia sufferers, to their carers and to future generations as a cornerstone of sound equality policy. That is something we could all support with enthusiasm and immense relief.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 715 c494-7
- Session
- 2009-10
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords chamber
- Subjects
- Children Curriculum Age Equality Health services Fees and charges Equal pay Discrimination Home care services Home education NHS Recruitment Poverty Primary education Personal, social, health and economic education Schools
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2023-12-08 16:37:20 +0000
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_597438
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_597438
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_597438